If you enjoy shopping for secondhand clothes, furniture, or unique items, you’ll love exploring the best thrift stores in Indianapolis. Thrift shopping is a great way to save money and find hidden treasures. Whether you’re looking for vintage clothes, home decor, or toys for your kids, there are many good spots around the city. Each store has its own style and things to offer. I visited several of them and picked my favorites to share with you.
In this guide, I talk about each thrift store in a simple way. I describe what you can find, what I liked most, and who the store is best for. I also included store hours, addresses, and phone numbers to help you plan your trip. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, these shops are worth checking out. I hope this list makes your thrift shopping easier and more fun.
Best Thrift Shops in Indianapolis – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mission 27 Resale | Affordable furniture, home decor | Trendy/high-end fashion | Budget-friendly | Clean, organized | Weekday mornings |
| Thrifty Threads | Budget-friendly clothing | Home goods/furniture | Very affordable | Casual, supportive | Weekday afternoons |
| Uptown Cheapskate NE | Brand-name, fashion-forward clothes | Vintage/antique finds | Mid-range | Bright, boutique-like | Weekends |
| Unique Thrift Store | Random treasures, cheap deals | Designer/upscale items | Super cheap | Crowded, treasure-hunt feel | Evenings |
| Salvation Army (Wash St) | Basic home items, supporting a cause | Modern/trendy styles | Very affordable | Simple, no-frills | Weekday afternoons |
| The Toggery Resale | Stylish women’s clothing/accessories | Men’s/kids’ items | Mid-range | Boutique, curated | Weekends |
| Humble Impressions | Digging for hidden deals | Quick shopping | Dirt cheap | Cozy, cluttered | Weekday afternoons |
| Goodwill Outlet | Bulk buys, pay-by-the-pound deals | Neatly organized shopping | Extremely cheap | Chaotic, treasure hunt | Early mornings |
| Habitat ReStore | Furniture/home improvement | Clothing/accessories | Budget-friendly | Organized, helpful staff | Weekday mornings |
| Peddlers Mall | Vintage/eclectic finds | Fast, in-and-out trips | Varies by seller | Flea market, bustling | Weekends |
| The Corner Bazaar | Vintage/retro collectors | Modern/new items | Mid-range | Funky, artsy | Weekend afternoons |
| Once Upon A Child | Kids’ clothes/toys | Adult items | Very affordable | Neat, family-friendly | Weekday mornings |
| Plato’s Closet | Trendy teen/young adult fashion | Older adult/kids’ clothes | Affordable | Bright, youthful | Weekends |
Mission 27 Resale
Mission 27 Resale is one of my favorite thrift stores to visit in the city. The store is clean and organized, which makes it easy to walk around without feeling overwhelmed. I’ve found all kinds of things here like used furniture, clothes, kitchen items, and decorations. The prices are fair, and the workers are always friendly and willing to help. I also like that the money goes toward helping people in the community, which makes shopping here feel even better.
This store has two locations in Indianapolis, and both are worth checking out. Every time I go in, I feel like I’m on a fun treasure hunt, and I almost always find something useful or interesting to take home. If you’re looking for affordable furniture, this is a great place to start. I’ve picked up some nice vintage pieces here that added a lot of character to my space. It’s a great shop whether you’re decorating your home or just browsing.
- Best for: Affordable furniture and organized browsing
- Not ideal for: Trendy or high-end fashion finds
- My top picks: Home décor, dressers, comfy chairs
- Location details:
📍 132 Leota St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
📞 (317) 687-8260
🕒 Mon–Fri: 10 AM–6 PM | Sat: 9 AM–5 PM | Sun: Closed
Thrifty Threads
Thrifty Threads is a store I like to visit when I want to shop for clothes at low prices. They have a large variety of men’s and women’s clothing, and most of it is in good condition. I’ve found nice shirts, jeans, jackets, and even a few purses here. What makes this place even better is that the money you spend helps support a local group that works with survivors of domestic violence. So, you can feel good about shopping here.
If you’re looking for budget-friendly clothing, this is one of the best thrift shops in Indianapolis. The store is roomy, which means you won’t feel crowded while you shop. The workers are also nice and quick to help you if you need anything. They don’t have much in terms of furniture or household stuff, but if you want clothes, it’s a solid spot to check out.
- Best for: Budget-friendly fashion and supporting a cause
- Not ideal for: Home goods or furniture shopping
- My top picks: Women’s tops, men’s jackets, purses
- Location details:
📍 1501 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46260
📞 (317) 802-9612
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–6 PM | Sun: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Shops in Fort Wayne
Uptown Cheapskate
Uptown Cheapskate NE doesn’t feel like a regular thrift store, it’s more like a trendy resale boutique. Most of the clothes here are newer and come from well-known brands like Nike, Urban Outfitters, and more. The store is bright, neat, and easy to look around in. I’ve found a lot of stylish stuff here for good prices. If you like to keep up with fashion without spending too much, this place is perfect.
This is one of the best consignment shops in the city, especially for teens and young adults. You can also sell your old clothes for store credit or cash, which is a nice bonus. The women’s section is big, and the men’s side has a decent selection too. It’s not the best store if you’re after vintage or older items, but if you want current fashion on a budget, this is the spot.
- Best for: Brand-name clothes and fashion-forward pieces
- Not ideal for: Vintage hunting or home items
- My top picks: Denim, casual sneakers, designer handbags
- Location details:
📍 5151 E 82nd St Ste 500 600, Indianapolis, IN 46250
📞 (317) 516-4731
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–8 PM | Sun: 12–5 PM
Unique Thrift Store
Unique Thrift Store is where I go when I feel like digging for good finds. It has a lot of items packed into one space, and the prices are very low. You can find clothes, toys, books, kitchen items, and sometimes even furniture. It’s not a fancy place, but that’s part of the fun, you never know what you’re going to find. I’ve picked up cool t-shirts, winter coats, and even working electronics here.
This is one of those hidden thrift store gems in Indianapolis. It might take a little time to go through everything, but if you enjoy hunting for deals, it’s worth the effort. The store stays open later than many others, which is helpful if you like to shop in the evening. It’s not the best place for designer fashion, but you can still find great everyday items at super cheap prices.
- Best for: Affordable, random treasures
- Not ideal for: Designer fashion or upscale presentation
- My top picks: Graphic tees, winter coats, used electronics
- Location details:
📍 2350 E 52nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
📞 (317) 252-4916
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–7 PM | Sun: 12–6 PM
The Salvation Army Family Store
The Salvation Army Family Store on Washington Street is a great spot when you want to shop with a purpose. The store is clean and well laid out, so it’s easy to look through everything. They sell a little bit of everything, clothes, furniture, kitchen items, and more. Prices are usually very reasonable, and the workers are kind. The money from sales goes to help people through their rehab programs, which is a big reason why I like coming here.
This store isn’t super stylish or trendy, but it’s steady and dependable. I’ve picked up things like a coffee table, dishes, and jackets that I still use today. It’s a great place to go when you want basic items for your home or wardrobe without spending too much. It’s also a good place to donate if you’re cleaning out your own closet.
- Best for: Supporting a good cause while thrifting
- Not ideal for: Super stylish or modern looks
- My top picks: Coffee tables, coats, dinnerware
- Location details:
📍 725 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
📞 (317) 236-1255
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–6 PM | Sun: Closed
The Toggery Resale Boutique
If you are into stylish clothing and name brands, The Toggery Resale Boutique is a great place to check out. This shop is clean, organized, and filled with good-quality women’s clothing, shoes, jewelry, and handbags. Everything is well-curated, so it feels more like shopping in a small boutique than a regular thrift store. The staff are super friendly and always happy to help.
I really liked how they have modern, up-to-date styles at affordable prices. It is one of those consignment shops in Indianapolis, Indiana where you can tell they really care about what they put on the racks. Whether you’re looking to refresh your wardrobe or find something cute for a night out, this is a great stop.
- Best for: Stylish women’s clothing
- Not ideal for: Men’s or kids’ items
- My top picks: Designer tops, purses, jewelry
- Location details:
📍 1810 Broad Ripple Ave Suite 4, Indianapolis, IN 46220
📞 (317) 257-5661
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–7 PM, Sunday: 12–5 PM
Related: Best Thrift Shops in Terre Haute
Humble Impressions
Humble Impressions is a small but packed thrift store where you never know what you’ll find. The prices are super low and the staff are always friendly. There are a lot of rooms to explore, and you’ll see everything from clothes to health and beauty items. It is one of those places that’s perfect for people who like to dig through stuff to find treasures.
If you enjoy spending time looking for good deals and do not mind a bit of hunting, this spot is worth visiting. As one of the more hidden thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana, it gives off a true “thrifting” vibe, and it’s fun to walk through and discover unexpected finds.
- Best for: Budget-friendly treasures and diggers
- Not ideal for: Quick shopping or highly organized layouts
- My top picks: Skincare, candles, cozy sweaters
- Location details:
📍 8238 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46227
📞 (317) 908-8635
🕒 Tuesday–Friday: 11 AM–5 PM, Saturday: 11 AM–4 PM, Closed Sunday & Monday
Goodwill Outlet Store
The Goodwill Outlet Store on Washington Street is a different kind of thrift shop. Instead of shopping from shelves or racks, everything is placed in large bins. You grab a cart and dig through to find clothes, books, toys, and even furniture. The best part is that you pay by the pound, so it’s a good place if you want to buy a lot without spending much. I once found a small sofa for under $15, which was an amazing deal.
This place may not be the cleanest or most organized, but it’s full of surprises if you take your time. It’s a bit of a treasure hunt, but I enjoy that part. If you’re searching for second hand stores in Indianapolis, Indiana that offer super low prices, this is worth checking out. Just bring gloves and wear comfy shoes, you might be here a while digging through the bins.
- Best for: Super low prices and bulk deals
- Not ideal for: Shoppers who want items hung or sorted neatly
- My top picks: Books, shoes, household goods
- Location details:
📍 6650 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
📞 (317) 524-4313
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–7 PM, Sunday: 12–7 PM
Habitat for Humanity ReStore
The Habitat for Humanity ReStore is one of my favorite places to shop for home items and furniture. Every time I visit, I find new things like dressers, kitchen cabinets, light fixtures, and even paint. Everything is donated, so the prices are much lower than regular stores. The workers are friendly and always offer to help if I have questions about the items. The store is also very clean and organized, which makes shopping easy.
One thing I really love is that the money you spend here helps build homes for families who need them. It feels good knowing that my purchase is also helping someone else. If you’re looking for furniture thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana, this store is a great place to start. You never know what you’ll find, and it’s a smart way to shop and support a good cause at the same time.
- Best for: Home improvement and furniture
- Not ideal for: Clothing or accessories
- My top picks: Lamps, office desks, paint supplies
- Location details:
📍 4129 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
📞 (317) 969-8790
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM, Closed Sunday
Peddlers Mall Flea Market
Peddlers Mall feels more like a giant indoor flea market than a regular thrift shop. There are rows and rows of small booths run by different sellers, so you’ll see all kinds of items. I’ve seen everything from vintage dressers and books to old records, tools, and handmade crafts. It’s a fun place to walk around, and you never know what you might find. You can easily spend a couple of hours just browsing.
This place is perfect if you like looking for unique items or want something unique for your home. Some booths have antiques, while others sell clothes, toys, or home goods. I think it truly belongs on the list of top 10 thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana because there’s just so much variety. I always leave with something interesting, even if I didn’t plan to buy anything.
- Best for: Variety and vintage treasures
- Not ideal for: Quick in-and-out shopping trips
- My top picks: Leather jackets, framed art, collectibles
- Location details:
📍 7803 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
📞 (317) 353-6710
🕒 Monday–Friday: 11 AM–7 PM, Saturday–Sunday: 10 AM–8 PM
The Corner Bazaar
The Corner Bazaar is one of the coolest vintage thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana I’ve been to. It’s located in the SoBro (South Broad Ripple) area and has a really fun mix of mid-century furniture, old records, vintage clothes, and unique decor. It feels more like walking into a funky museum than a regular store. The owner and staff are super nice and make you feel welcome right away.
Everything in the store seems hand-picked with care. I found a vintage lamp and an old denim jacket that I absolutely love. If you’re into retro style or antique items, this is definitely a spot worth checking out. It’s not a huge place, but it’s packed with charm and good finds.
- Best for: Vintage lovers and collectors
- Not ideal for: People looking for modern or new items
- My top picks: Mid-century furniture, records, vintage jackets
- Location details:
📍 1105 E 52nd St, Indianapolis, IN 46205
📞 (317) 377-4639
🕒 Thursday–Friday: 11 AM–6 PM, Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM, Sunday: 11 AM–5 PM, Closed Monday–Wednesday
Once Upon A Child
Once Upon A Child on Rockville Road is one of the top rated thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana for parents with growing kids. As a mom, I love shopping and selling here because it helps me save money and clear out things my child no longer uses. They pay cash right away for gently used baby and kids’ clothes, toys, and other gear. The store is always organized, and the staff are super friendly and helpful. I never feel rushed, and it’s easy to find what I’m looking for.
I’ve found so many great deals here, baby clothes, shoes, books, and even strollers and play sets. Most of the items are name-brand and in very good shape. It’s also nice to sell the things my child has outgrown and use that money to shop right away. If you have kids and want to stay on a budget, this is a smart place to go. I visit often and always leave with something useful.
- Best for: Baby and kids’ clothing and gear
- Not ideal for: Adult clothing or furniture
- My top picks: Baby clothes, toddler shoes, used toys
- Location details:
📍 8238 Rockville Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46214
📞 (317) 273-8622
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–8 PM, Sunday: 11 AM–6 PM
Plato’s Closet
Plato’s Closet is one of my favorite clothing thrift stores in Indianapolis, Indiana for finding cute and affordable outfits. I shop here when I want something stylish without spending a lot of money. They buy and sell gently used clothes that still look new. The clothes are trendy and great for teens and young adults who want to stay in style. The store is always clean, and the staff is friendly and happy to help.
I’ve picked up some great deals on brand-name items like jeans, shoes, and jackets. I like how they always have clothes that match the season, so it’s easy to find what I need. The prices are way lower than regular stores, and the quality is still really good. If you like fashion and saving money, this place is a must-visit. I always leave with something I love.
- Best for: Trendy, affordable clothes for teens and young adults
- Not ideal for: Older adults or kids’ clothing
- My top picks: Name-brand jeans, crossbody bags, casual dresses
- Location details:
📍 9391 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46229
📞 (317) 895-1930
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–9 PM, Sunday: 12–6 PM
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Indianapolis can be a fun and budget-friendly way to find clothes, furniture, and all kinds of cool things. Each store has something special, whether it’s vintage items, kids’ clothes, or gently used furniture. I had a great time visiting these places and finding hidden gems. If you enjoy saving money and hunting for unique items, these stores are definitely worth a visit. I hope this list helps you find your new favorite thrift store in the city!
