If you’re like me, there’s nothing better than spending a day looking for unique items in the best thrift stores in York. Whether it’s a vintage jacket, an old book, or some stylish home items, York has something for everyone to explore. The thrift stores here are full of personality, great prices, and rare things you won’t find in regular stores. I spent time visiting different shops around York to show you the best ones.
In this guide, I’ll take you along with me through some of my favorite thrift stores in town. I’ll share what each store is really good at, what they might not be ideal for, and my top picks from each place. Think of it like shopping with a friend who loves thrifting just as much as you do! Ready to dive into some amazing secondhand shopping? Let’s get started!
Best Thrift Shops in York – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price Range | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Uptown Cheapskate | Trendy, brand-name clothing | Vintage/classic styles | Mid-range ($10-$40) | Organized, youthful | Weekday mornings |
| CommunityAid | Huge variety (clothes, furniture) | Quick, specific finds | Budget-friendly ($3-$30) | Busy, community-focused | Early weekends |
| The Harvest Consignment | Plus-size women’s fashion | Men’s/smaller sizes | Affordable ($8-$35) | Cozy, curated | Friday afternoons |
| My Girlfriend’s Wardrobe | Designer/secondhand gems | Cheap basics | Higher-end ($20-$100+) | Boutique, polished | Weekday afternoons |
| Feral Heart Club | Bold vintage & handmade art | Minimalist styles | Fair ($15-$50) | Artsy, eclectic | Weekends |
| Refindings | Vintage furniture & home decor | Clothing/accessories | Varied ($20-$200) | Rustic, DIY-friendly | Saturday mornings |
| Top Drawer | Brand-name deals (clothes, home) | Neat, minimalist shoppers | Bargains ($5-$50) | Packed, treasure-hunt feel | Early weekdays |
| Re-Source York | Budget furniture & home goods | Fashion shopping | Super cheap ($5-$150) | Warehouse, practical | Weekday afternoons |
| Kid to Kid York | Kids’ clothes/toys | Adult shoppers | Low ($3-$25) | Bright, family-friendly | Weekday mornings |
| Love Me 2 Times | Stylish women’s consignment | Men’s/kids’ items | Mid-range ($12-$60) | Chic, boutique-like | Weekday afternoons |
| Artemis Vintage | True vintage clothing/accessories | Fast-fashion lovers | Fair ($10-$75) | Retro, well-organized | Saturday afternoons |
| In Between Pages | Rare/used books | New releases | Cheap ($2-$20) | Quiet, cozy | Weekend afternoons |
| Revolt Style Studio | Vintage-modern fusion fashion | Bargain-bin hunters | Premium ($25-$120) | Edgy, curated | Friday evenings |
| Twice as Sweet Kids’ | Gently-used kids’ gear | Non-kid shoppers | Budget-friendly ($4-$30) | Clean, cheerful | Weekday mornings |
Uptown Cheapskate
Whenever I want trendy fashion without spending too much, Uptown Cheapskate is my first stop. The store has a nice setup, and it’s so easy to find styles that feel current and fresh. I always find a variety of casual wear, party outfits, and name-brand pieces at great prices.
The shopping experience here is organized, not overwhelming like some thrift stores. Plus, the staff is helpful if you need help picking out something. If you love following trends but don’t want to pay full price, this place is perfect.
They focus mostly on young adult and teen clothing, so if you’re looking for classic, timeless pieces, you might not find a lot here. Still, it’s fun to dig through their racks for trendy jackets, sneakers, and statement bags. I almost always walk out with something stylish that feels brand-new.
- Best For: Trendy, brand-name clothing at affordable prices
- Not Ideal For: Shoppers hunting for vintage or classic timeless styles
- My Top Picks: Denim jackets, stylish handbags, and casual sneakers
- Location Details:
- Located in: West Manchester Town Center
- Address: 860 Town Center Dr, York, PA 17408
- Phone: (717) 724-9602
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 9 AM–8 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM–4 PM
Top Drawer
Top Drawer consignment shop is a great place if you like finding lots of different things in one store. They have clothes, shoes, home items, and accessories all packed together. I saw a lot of good brands at really fair prices. It was fun to look through the racks and find nice surprises. The staff was friendly and let me take my time without bothering me.
This store is best if you enjoy searching through lots of items to find good deals. If you like very neat and simple stores, this one might feel a little too full. There are many choices, but you might have to spend some time looking around. It is a good spot if you are patient and love finding rare items.
- Best for: Brand name finds at great prices.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers who prefer a neatly curated layout.
- My Top Picks: Coach handbags, casual dresses, and decorative candles.
- Location Details:
- Address: 2331 E Market St #5, York, PA 17402
- Phone: (717) 840-3844
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–4 PM
CommunityAid
CommunityAid is one of those places where you can easily spend hours just looking around. The store is huge and filled with everything from clothing to furniture, plus they always seem to have new stuff coming in. I like that their prices are fair, and the store feels very community-focused, which makes donating and shopping even better.
You can find almost anything if you’re willing to dig a little. It’s definitely the place I go when I want variety without breaking the bank. While it’s great for big finds, it can sometimes feel a little overwhelming because of the size.
If you’re looking for something very specific and don’t like searching through a lot of items, it might not be the easiest trip. Still, the items you can find here are totally worth it. I always come back for the book section, winter coats, and kitchen goods.
- Best For: Wide variety of secondhand items and great deals
- Not Ideal For: Quick shopping trips for something very specific
- My Top Picks: Cozy winter coats, kitchen essentials, and fiction books
- Location Details:
- Located in: Queensgate Towne Center
- Address: 2001 Springwood Rd, York, PA 17403
- Phone: (717) 412-7706
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 9 AM–9 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Lancaster
The Harvest Consignment
The Harvest Consignment is a great spot, especially if you wear plus sizes and want stylish options. The store is very neat, easy to search, and everything is handpicked with care. It’s not a giant store, but that’s what makes shopping here so comfortable and stress-free.
Every time I visit, I find unique outfits that actually fit well, which isn’t always easy at other thrift shops. Plus, the ladies working there are super friendly and give great style advice. Because it mainly focuses on plus-size fashion, options for smaller sizes are really limited. If you’re looking for men’s clothes or kids’ stuff, this won’t be your store.
But if you want fashionable plus-size clothes without spending a fortune, this place is a total win. I usually grab pretty tops, workwear, and cozy sweaters whenever I stop by.
- Best For: Plus-size women’s clothing with stylish and trendy choices
- Not Ideal For: Men’s clothing or smaller women’s sizes
- My Top Picks: Printed blouses, cozy sweaters, and office dresses
- Location Details:
- Address: 729 E Market St, York, PA 17403
- Phone: (717) 318-1926
- Operating Hours:
- Friday: 12 PM–7 PM
- Saturday: 12–5 PM
- Sunday-Thursday: Closed
My Girlfriend’s Wardrobe
Whenever I want to find beautiful secondhand designer pieces, I visit My Girlfriend’s Wardrobe. The shop is clean and everything is displayed so nicely that shopping feels like a real boutique experience. I’ve found some awesome handbags, heels, and work clothes here without paying crazy prices.
It’s one of those stores where you can tell the owners really care about quality and style. I always get excited to check their new arrivals section first! If you’re hunting for everyday cheap basics, this store might feel a bit pricey compared to regular thrifting.
They focus on mid-range to high-end brands, so it’s better for when you’re looking for something special. Even so, I can’t resist their great finds. I usually leave with a pretty blouse, designer shoes, or a polished handbag.
- Best For: Gently-used designer clothing and accessories
- Not Ideal For: Bargain shoppers hunting for ultra-cheap basics
- My Top Picks: Crossbody bags, polished blouses, and stylish heels
- Location Details:
- Address: 38 N Beaver St, York, PA 17401
- Phone: (717) 668-3020
- Operating Hours:
- Monday & Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
- Tuesday-Thursday: 10 AM–6 PM
- Friday: 10 AM–7 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM–2 PM
Related: Best Thrift Stores In State College
Feral Heart Club
Feral Heart Club is a unique and artsy spot that is a great place for vintage lovers. They have racks of funky, colorful clothes, cool handmade jewelry, and original artwork. If you want pieces that are unique and rare, this store is a dream. Plus, the prices are totally fair for such unique finds.
This store is best if you’re into bold, artistic looks. If you like really basic or minimalist styles, it might not match your vibe. But for creative outfits or statement pieces, it’s amazing. I always look for oversized jackets, funky earrings, and graphic tees whenever I visit.
- Best For: Unique vintage fashion and artistic finds
- Not Ideal For: Basic or super minimal wardrobe shoppers
- My Top Picks: Colorful jackets, handmade jewelry, and vintage graphic tees
- Location Details:
Located in: Central Market House
Address: 49 N Beaver St, York, PA 17401
Phone: (717) 919-1515
Operating Hours:
Sunday & Tuesday: 10 AM–4 PM
Thursday: 10 AM–5 PM
Friday-Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
Monday & Wednesday: Closed
Refindings
Refindings is a great place if you like old furniture and home stuff. They have all kinds of vintage items like chairs, tables, light fixtures, doors, and old sinks. The store is clean and everything is easy to see.
The staff was nice and helped me when I had questions about a few pieces. I liked that they had good prices and things for both small and big budgets. This is a great place if you like decorating your home with old and unique pieces. There are lots of things you can fix up or use in your house.
It is not a good spot if you are looking for clothes or shoes because they mostly sell furniture and home items. If you enjoy finding special things for your home, you will really like it here. There is a lot to look at and it is easy to spend a lot of time.
- Best for: Antique furniture, vintage decor, DIY materials.
- Not ideal for: Clothing or accessories shopping.
- My Top Picks: Vintage mirrors, old wooden tables, and quirky light fixtures.
- Location Details:
- Address: 465 E Prospect St, York, PA 17403
- Phone: (717) 854-7152
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Tuesday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Wednesday: Closed
- Thursday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Friday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–5 PM
Re-Source York
Re-Source York is a really good place if you are trying to furnish a home without spending too much money. They have lots of gently used furniture like couches, tables, chairs, and even beds. You can also find kitchen items, building supplies, and some home decor.
The prices were much cheaper than buying new, and everything looked clean and ready to use. The staff was very kind and answered all my questions with a smile. This store is great if you need furniture, tools, or things for fixing up your house. They have a wide mix of items, and new stuff comes in all the time.
If you are shopping for clothes, shoes, or fashion, this is not the right place because they mostly focus on home goods. It is also nice to know that when you buy from here, you are helping support the local community. I would definitely visit again if I needed anything for my home.
- Best for: Used furniture, home improvement items, and budget shopping.
- Not ideal for: Fashion and clothing shopping.
- My Top Picks: Bookshelves, kitchen chairs, and cabinet hardware.
- Location Details:
- Address: 405 Carlisle Ave, York, PA 17404
- Phone: (717) 718-3182
- Operating Hours:
- Sunday & Monday: Closed
- Tuesday-Friday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM–4 PM
Kid to Kid York
Kid to Kid York is a really bright and happy store. They had lots of kids’ clothes, shoes, toys, and even baby gear all neatly arranged. Everything looked clean and almost like new, and the prices were much lower than regular stores. I also noticed they had maternity clothes, which was great for moms-to-be.
The workers were very nice and helped me find different sizes when I needed them. This store is perfect if you are shopping for babies, kids, or expecting moms and want to save money. They have a huge selection and it is easy to find what you need.
If you do not have kids or are not shopping for little ones, there is not much for you here. But if you are a parent or buying a gift for a child, this store makes it really easy and affordable.
- Best for: Children’s clothing, shoes, toys, and maternity gear.
- Not ideal for: Adult shoppers without kid needs.
- My Top Picks: Toddler winter jackets, baby shoes, and learning toys.
- Location Details:
- Located in: Heights Plaza
- Address: 180 Leader Heights Rd, York, PA 17402
- Phone: (717) 747-5437
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 9 AM–8 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–5 PM
Love Me 2 Times Consignment Boutique
Love Me 2 Times Consignment Boutique is a small but very nice shop. It is full of stylish women’s clothes, handbags, and jewelry. They have a good mix of casual and dressy outfits, and everything looked clean and well cared for.
Prices were fair, and the store was easy to look through without feeling crowded. The staff said hello when I came in and were happy to help if I needed anything. This boutique is a good place for women who want fashionable secondhand items at fair prices.
If you are shopping for men’s clothes or kids’ stuff, this store may not have what you are looking for. But if you love finding nice outfits and accessories for less, it is a great stop.
- Best for: Stylish women’s clothing, shoes, and accessories.
- Not ideal for: Men’s or children’s clothing shoppers.
- My Top Picks: Statement necklaces, sweaters, and designer handbags.
- Location Details:
- Located in: Olde Tollgate Village
- Address: 2555 S Queen St, York, PA 17402
- Phone: (717) 741-5000
- Operating Hours:
- Monday, Wednesday & Sunday: Closed
- Tuesday, Thursday & Friday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–3:30 PM
Artemis Vintage
Artemis Vintage is a great spot for people who love vintage fashion. The store was neat and easy to shop, with racks full of old-school clothes, accessories, and some fun home items. It was simple to find sizes, and everything looked clean and in good shape.
I noticed a lot of different styles from different decades, which made it even more interesting. Prices were fair for real vintage pieces, and it was nice to see that nothing looked too worn out or damaged. This shop is a good pick if you are into true vintage style and special finds.
There are many unique pieces that you probably will not find anywhere else. If you want the latest fashion trends or brand-new clothing, this store may not be the right place for you. It is more about classic, older styles that have real character. I would definitely stop by again if I needed something special and different.
- Best for: Vintage clothing, accessories, and collectibles.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for brand-new or trendy fast fashion.
- My Top Picks: 70s denim jackets, vintage brooches, and retro graphic tees.
- Location Details:
- Address: 57 N Beaver St, York, PA 17401
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday-Friday & Sunday: 12 PM–4 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
In Between Pages
In Between Pages is a huge used bookstore with shelves full of every kind of book you can think of. There were spots where you could sit down and look through old paperbacks or rare books. Everything was organized by topic, which made it easy to find what you were looking for.
The store was very quiet, and it was easy to spend a long time just browsing. The prices were really good, especially if you are hunting for older or hard-to-find books. This store is perfect for people who love reading and collecting secondhand books. There is a big mix of fiction, non-fiction, kids’ books, and even some rare editions.
If you are looking for the newest bestsellers or just-released books, this might not be the best stop. Most of the books are older, but that is part of the fun. It is a great spot to visit if you enjoy taking your time and finding special books you would not see in big chain stores.
- Best for: Used books, rare finds, and quiet book browsing.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for the newest releases.
- My Top Picks: Vintage science fiction novels, classic poetry books, and quirky nonfiction titles.
- Location Details:
- Address: 113 S Duke St, York, PA 17401
- Phone: (717) 846-2866
- Operating Hours:
- Monday & Tuesday: Closed
- Wednesday-Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM–6 PM
Revolt Style Studio
Revolt Style Studio is a bright and neat store with a variety of vintage clothes, trendy accessories, and some newer fashion too. Everything was sorted by color and style, which made it easy to find what I liked. The owner was in the shop and was very helpful when I had questions about sizes and styles.
I saw a lot of creative and bold pieces that would be great for building a stylish wardrobe. The store was clean, well-organized, and easy to walk around. This shop is a good choice if you like vintage clothes that still feel fresh and trendy. Most of the pieces are special and not something you see everywhere.
If you are looking for low prices or racks full of random items, you might want to try a different store. Revolt Style Studio feels more like a boutique with handpicked items. It is a nice place to visit if you want something different for your closet.
- Best for: Vintage fashion with a modern twist.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for large thrift store pricing.
- My Top Picks: Statement jackets, funky sunglasses, and bold patterned shirts.
- Location Details:
- Address: 26 N Beaver St, York, PA 17401
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday, Thursday & Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
- Wednesday: Closed
- Friday: 10 AM–9 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM–2 PM
Twice as Sweet Kids’ Closet
Twice as Sweet Kids’ Closet is a great place for families looking to shop. The store is well-organized by size and type, making it simple to find what you need. They have a good selection of baby clothes, children’s shoes, toys, and even maternity items.
The prices are very reasonable, and everything looked almost new. The store was bright, clean, and had a fresh smell, which is always nice when shopping for kids.
This store is perfect for finding affordable, high-quality clothing for children. If you’re not shopping for kids, though, you may not find much that fits your needs. It’s a must-visit if you need something for your little ones.
- Best for: Gently used kids’ clothing, toys, and baby gear.
- Not ideal for: Adult clothing or home decor shopping.
- My Top Picks: Baby onesies, children’s winter coats, and toddler sneakers.
- Location Details:
- Address: 3917 E Market St, York, PA 17402
- Phone: (717) 318-5144
- Operating Hours:
- Tuesday-Saturday: 10 AM–7 PM
- Sunday & Monday: Closed
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Words
Shopping at thrift stores in York has been such a fun time, and I hope this guide helps you find some awesome stuff too. Every shop had something special, and that’s what makes thrifting here so exciting. Whether you want clothes, home decorations, or vintage items, York has a little bit of everything. Have fun thrifting.
