The best thrift stores in Mentor offer a fantastic range of deals for any thrift lover. Whether you’re searching for clothing, home decor, or accessories, Mentor, Ohio, has plenty of great options to explore. These stores are not only affordable, but they also offer a variety of items, so you’re sure to leave with something special. From big chain stores like The Salvation Army to local favorites like Plato’s Closet, Mentor has something for every type of thrift shopper.
In this article, I’ll share my personal experiences at some of the top thrift and consignment stores in Mentor, Ohio. You’ll find a mix of places to score incredible deals, whether you’re shopping for everyday wear or hunting for unique finds. Each store has its own charm, and I’ll break down what makes them stand out, along with my top picks from each location. Let’s dive into the best spots to visit and what they have to offer!
Best Thrift Shops in Mentor – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plato’s Closet | Trendy teen/young adult fashion | Vintage or unique items | Slightly higher thrift | Bright, youthful | Weekends (new arrivals) |
| Salvation Army Thrift Store | Affordable clothes, home decor | High-end brands | Very budget-friendly | Organized, charitable | Weekday mornings |
| Once Upon A Child | Kids’ clothes, toys, baby gear | Adult clothing | Great deals for parents | Family-friendly | Weekday afternoons |
| Christ Child Clothing Cottage | Women’s/kids’ clothes, formal wear | Household items | Super affordable | Cozy, community-focused | Midweek (limited hours) |
| Kicks In The 216 | Sneakers & athletic shoes | Non-shoe items | Fair for rare finds | Sporty, hypebeast-friendly | Afternoons (new drops) |
| Birthright Lake | Free/low-cost baby essentials | Non-baby items | Free/donation-based | Supportive, warm | Weekday mornings |
| Timeless Treasures | Antiques, vintage furniture | Modern décor | Mid-range vintage | Quirky, treasure-hunt feel | Weekend afternoons |
| Hannah’s Home | Maternity/baby items | General shopping | Free/donation-based | Caring, nonprofit vibe | Call ahead (hours vary) |
| Amvets Post 40 | Military memorabilia, household goods | Designer/luxury items | Bargain prices | Casual, veteran-supported | Weekday mornings |
| Five Below | Cheap new toys, snacks, décor | High-quality/long-lasting items | Everything under $5 | Bright, fun | Anytime (well-stocked) |
| JCPenney | Family clothing, clearance deals | Boutique/high-fashion | Department store sales | Spacious, reliable | Weekdays (avoid weekends) |
Plato’s Closet Mentor
If you’re after trendy, gently used clothing, Plato’s Closet in Mentor is a great option. The store has a fantastic selection of fashionable items, including shoes, accessories, and casual wear, perfect for anyone looking to update their wardrobe with stylish pieces. Whether you’re on the hunt for a new pair of jeans or a cool jacket, you’ll likely find it here.
The store is clean, well-organized, and easy to browse, making the shopping experience enjoyable. They even carry some popular brands that are a bit harder to find at other thrift stores, so it’s a great place for finding trendy items that are still affordable.
However, keep in mind that Plato’s Closet tends to have slightly higher prices compared to other thrift stores, as they cater to a younger, trendier crowd. While the prices may be a little more than what you’d expect from a typical thrift store, it’s worth it for the high-quality items and fashionable finds.
The store’s hours are convenient for a quick visit, whether you’re in the mood for a weekend shopping spree or looking for something specific after work. If you’re looking for trendy clothes that won’t break the bank, Plato’s Closet is definitely worth checking out.
- Best for: Teen and young adult fashion, including trendy shoes and accessories.
- Not ideal for: Vintage or unique items.
- My Top Picks: The jeans and athletic wear sections are always stocked with great options.
Location
- Address: 7600 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 602-9790
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 9 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 6 PM
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
The Salvation Army in Mentor is a solid spot for second-hand shopping, especially if you’re looking for a variety of items. They offer a great selection of clothes, shoes, toys, and household goods, so you can always find something useful. The store is well-organized, which makes it easy to navigate and find exactly what you’re looking for.
It’s one of those places where you can quickly find affordable, gently used items that still have a lot of life left in them. Whether you’re in need of some new clothes or searching for a unique piece of home decor, you’re sure to find something here. The prices are reasonable, making it a great place for budget-conscious shoppers. Plus, the staff is always friendly and helpful, which adds to the overall positive experience.
In addition to the variety and cleanliness of the store, The Salvation Army in Mentor is a great place to drop off donations as well. They have a simple donation process, and it’s nice knowing that your items are going to help others in the community. The store’s hours are convenient too, so you can easily swing by after work or on the weekend.
If you enjoy finding deals while supporting a good cause, this is the place to go. Whether you’re an experienced thrifter or just getting started, you’ll feel welcomed here. Don’t forget to check out their seasonal items, which are always a fun surprise.
- Best for: Affordable clothing, furniture, and household items.
- Not ideal for: High-end or designer brands.
- My Top Picks: I love the variety of home decor and vintage finds they often have.
Location
- Address: 7000 Heisley Rd, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (800) 728-7825
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 7 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Once Upon A Child Mentor
Once Upon A Child is perfect for families looking for gently used kids’ clothing and toys. The store has an excellent selection of everything from baby gear to children’s books and seasonal items like coats and costumes, making it a one-stop shop for parents in need of affordable, quality items.
Whether you’re stocking up on everyday clothes for your little one or looking for something special like a Halloween costume, this store has you covered. The prices are often lower than what you’d find at traditional retail stores, making it a great option for parents trying to save money while still getting quality items.
The staff at Once Upon A Child is another highlight, as they are always friendly and welcoming, making the shopping experience even more enjoyable. The store is well-organized, so it’s easy to find exactly what you’re looking for without wasting time.
With everything from toys to clothes and gear, Once Upon A Child is a must-visit for families who want to shop smart without compromising on quality. Whether you’re shopping for everyday items or something a little extra, you’ll likely find a great deal here.
- Best for: Gently-used children’s clothing, toys, and baby gear.
- Not ideal for: Adult clothing or furniture.
- My Top Picks: The toy section always has some great finds, especially during the holiday season.
Location
- Address: 7531 Mentor Ave UNIT 16, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 951-7222
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 8 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 6 PM
Related: Best Thrift Shops In Mansfield Ohio
Christ Child Clothing Cottage
Christ Child Clothing Cottage is a wonderful place for affordable, gently used clothing. The store offers a carefully curated selection that includes everything from casual wear to more formal attire, so you’ll find a variety of options to suit your style. The prices are very reasonable, making it a budget-friendly spot for anyone looking to update their wardrobe without spending too much money.
One of the highlights of shopping here is the friendly and helpful staff, who always go the extra mile to assist you in finding what you need. Whether you’re looking for something for work, a special occasion, or just everyday wear, Christ Child Clothing Cottage has you covered.
The only drawback is that the store’s hours are a bit limited, so you’ll need to plan your visit around their schedule. It’s a smaller store, so the selection might not be as vast as larger thrift shops, but the quality of the items makes it well worth a stop.
Plus, their commitment to providing affordable clothing for the community makes shopping here feel even better. If you can catch them during their open hours, you’ll likely leave with some great finds at a fantastic price.
- Best for: Affordable women’s and children’s clothing.
- Not ideal for: A wide variety of household items.
- My Top Picks: I’ve found some fantastic winter coats and dresses here.
Location
- Address: 9324 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 350-9836
- Operating Hours:
- Tuesday-Saturday: 11 AM – 3 PM
- Sunday-Monday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores In Cuyahoga Falls Ohio
Kicks In The 216
Kicks In The 216 is a sneaker lover’s paradise! If you’re looking for a variety of shoes, especially athletic and trendy brands, this store is definitely worth a visit. They have a great selection of both new and gently-used sneakers, which means you can find some unique pairs that aren’t easily available at other stores.
Whether you’re searching for the latest releases or classic styles, you’ll find something that fits your style here. The store is always clean, well-organized, and easy to shop in, making your visit a pleasant one. What really stands out about Kicks In The 216 is the helpful staff. They’re very knowledgeable about sneakers, so if you’re not sure what you’re looking for, they can guide you to the perfect pair.
Whether you’re after athletic shoes for sports, casual sneakers for everyday wear, or something special, the staff will make sure you find the right fit. The combination of a great selection, friendly service, and an easy-to-navigate store makes this a top choice for sneaker fans in Mentor.
- Best for: Athletic shoes and sneakers, including hard-to-find styles.
- Not ideal for: Non-shoe items or high-fashion clothing.
- My Top Picks: The limited-edition sneakers section is where I’ve found some of my best deals.
Location
- Address: 7850 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 290-7990
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 11 AM – 8 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 6 PM
Birthright Lake
Birthright Lake is a nonprofit organization that offers vital support to mothers and families in need. Although it’s not a traditional thrift store, it provides gently used baby clothes, toys, and other baby essentials, making it an invaluable resource for parents. The store’s staff is one of its best features, as they are warm, welcoming, and always ready to help.
They go above and beyond to assist families, ensuring that they get the items they need in a caring and supportive environment. This makes Birthright Lake an essential part of the community, especially for those going through tough times. Not only does Birthright Lake provide affordable baby items, but they also offer a sense of comfort and security to parents.
Whether you’re looking for baby clothes, toys, strollers, or other essentials, you’ll find gently-used options at affordable prices. The staff’s kindness and dedication to the cause make a huge difference. They take the time to listen to each family’s needs and make sure they leave with exactly what they need. If you’re a parent or caregiver in the Mentor area, Birthright Lake is a wonderful place to find the support and baby items you might need.
- Best for: Baby clothes, toys, and baby essentials.
- Not ideal for: Adult clothing or furniture.
- My Top Picks: The baby clothes section is always stocked with items in excellent condition.
Location
- Address: 7237 Industrial Park Blvd, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 975-9055
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Thursday: 9 AM – 4 PM
- Friday-Sunday: Closed
Timeless Treasures on the Avenue
Timeless Treasures on the Avenue is a great place for anyone who loves antiques and collectibles. The store is packed with a wide range of vintage items, including furniture, decorative pieces, and other unique treasures. Whether you’re searching for a special antique to add character to your home or a collectible to complete your collection, you’ll find something interesting here.
The prices are fair for the quality of the items, and you can tell the store takes care in selecting what it offers. The store’s cozy and welcoming atmosphere makes browsing a pleasant experience. The friendly staff is always available to help if you need assistance or have questions about any of the items.
Whether you’re a seasoned collector or just someone who appreciates vintage finds, Timeless Treasures on the Avenue is the perfect place to explore. You’ll enjoy the hunt for unique pieces that add charm and history to your home. If you love antiques, this store should definitely be on your list.
- Best for: Antiques, vintage furniture, and collectibles.
- Not ideal for: Modern or trendy items.
- My Top Picks: I’ve found some beautiful vintage lamps and furniture pieces here.
Location
- Address: 8444 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060
- Operating Hours:
- Tuesday-Saturday: 11 AM – 6 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 4 PM
- Monday: Closed
Hannah’s Home
Hannah’s Home is a caring place that helps women who need support, especially while raising young children. While it’s not exactly a regular thrift store, they do give out gently used items like baby clothes, diapers, blankets, and other things that families might need.
The main focus of Hannah’s Home is to provide love, care, and support for women during tough times. They really try to make sure moms feel safe, understood, and not alone. It’s more than just a place to get free or low-cost items, it’s a place that truly wants to help people. The space is clean and neat, and everything is set up so it’s easy to look around and find what you’re looking for. The people who work there are very kind, patient, and always ready to listen or offer help.
They take the time to make sure everyone feels welcome and respected. Even though it’s not a big store, the help they give means a lot. If you or someone you know needs help during pregnancy or early parenting, Hannah’s Home is a great place to find support and helpful items.
- Best for: Maternity clothes, baby essentials, and children’s items.
- Not ideal for: Non-baby or maternity items.
- My Top Picks: The baby clothes and maternity wear sections are great for new parents.
Location
- Address: 8525 Lakeshore Blvd #1516, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 209-9615
- Operating Hours:
- Hours vary, please contact for details.
Amvets Post 40
Amvets Post 40 is a great spot if you’re looking for gently-used items at good prices. They carry a wide mix of things like clothing, kitchenware, furniture, and even military memorabilia. It’s the kind of place where you never know what you might find, which makes it fun to explore.
The items are usually in nice condition, and the prices are affordable, which is helpful if you’re trying to stick to a budget. Whether you need something practical or you’re looking for a unique vintage piece, they have a bit of everything. The store itself is easy to walk through, and the shelves are pretty well organized.
The staff there are friendly and always willing to help if you have questions or need assistance. There’s a relaxed and welcoming feeling to the place, which makes it comfortable to shop around. It’s also a nice bonus to know your purchases support veterans and the community. Amvets Post 40 is definitely worth checking out if you’re in Mentor and enjoy finding secondhand treasures.
- Best for: Clothing, household goods, and military memorabilia.
- Not ideal for: Designer items or high-end products.
- My Top Picks: I’ve picked up some great vintage jackets and cool military collectibles here.
Location
- Address: 9141 Jordan Dr, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 257-5825
- Operating Hours:
- Hours vary, please contact for details.
Five Below
While not exactly a thrift store, Five Below is still a great place for budget-friendly shopping in Mentor. The store carries a wide range of new items, including toys, tech accessories, home decor, snacks, and seasonal goods. Almost everything in the store is priced at five dollars or less, which makes it an easy spot to stick to your budget.
If you’re shopping for kids, dorm room items, or just fun little extras, you can usually find something useful or entertaining here without spending a lot. The store is bright, clean, and laid out in a way that makes browsing simple. Each section is clearly labeled, so it doesn’t take long to find what you need.
The shelves are usually well-stocked, and they get new things in often, so it’s worth stopping by now and then. Even though the prices are low, the quality of the items is generally pretty good for what you pay. If you want affordable, brand-new items without the hunt that comes with thrift shopping, Five Below is a solid choice.
- Best for: Budget-friendly toys, home decor, and snacks.
- Not ideal for: High-quality, long-lasting goods.
- My Top Picks: I always stop by for their affordable phone accessories and seasonal items.
Location
- Address: 9559 Mentor Ave, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 354-1433
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 9 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM – 7 PM
JCPenney
JCPenney in Mentor is a great place to shop for affordable clothing and everyday items. It’s located inside the Great Lakes Mall, so it’s convenient if you’re already out shopping. The store has a wide selection for men, women, and kids, including everything from casual outfits to dressy clothes.
They also carry shoes, accessories, and home items, so you can find a lot in one trip. The layout is easy to follow, and the shelves and racks are usually well-stocked and tidy. One thing I noticed during my visit is how clean the dressing rooms are, especially in the women’s section, which makes trying things on more comfortable.
The staff was friendly and quick to help when I had questions about sizes or sales. JCPenney often runs promotions and discounts, so you can usually find a good deal on name-brand items. If you’re shopping for the whole family or just want to check out a dependable department store, this is a solid stop.
- Best for: Affordable family clothing and accessories.
- Not ideal for: High-end or boutique-style items.
- My Top Picks: I always find great deals in their clearance section for clothes and home items.
Location
- Address: 7850 Mentor Ave Suite 930, Mentor, OH 44060
- Phone: (440) 255-4461
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Thursday: 11 AM – 8 PM
- Friday-Saturday: 10 AM – 9 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 7 PM
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Words
No matter what you’re on the hunt for, Mentor has a wide variety of thrift stores that offer great deals and unique finds. From gently used clothes to quirky home decor and everything in between, you’re bound to discover something special. Each store has its own vibe and selection, so take the time to explore them all.
Whether you’re an experienced thrifter or just starting out, these stores are worth checking out. Happy shopping, and I hope you find your next favorite piece!
