If you love finding good deals and secondhand items, you’ll enjoy checking out the best thrift stores in Elyria. Whether you’re looking for clothes, furniture, or something totally unexpected, Elyria has a nice mix of local spots where you can shop without spending too much. I’ve spent time visiting each of these stores to see what they offer, and every one of them has something different to like.
Some shops are great for vintage vibes, while others are packed with everyday basics or home items. I’ve found fun gifts, brand-name clothes, and some unique collectibles while shopping around town. In this list, I’ll share my personal favorites, what each store is best for, and what you might want to skip, so you can plan your next thrift trip with ease.
Best Thrift Shops in Elyria – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price Range | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vintage Vibes | Retro decor, rare vintage pieces | Modern/bulk clothing | Mid-range ($10–$50) | Nostalgic, curated | Weekday afternoons |
| New To You Resale Shop | Quality clothing, consignment finds | Super cheap deals | Moderate ($15–$60) | Clean, organized | Weekday mornings |
| Roxy’s Emporium | Handmade goods, quirky gifts | Basic wardrobe staples | Affordable ($5–$40) | Artsy, cozy | Weekends |
| Goodwill (Abbe Rd) | Affordable clothes, household items | Boutique-style thrifting | Budget-friendly ($3–$20) | Spacious, well-stocked | Early weekdays |
| Discount Fashion Warehouse | Brand-name clothes, new items | Vintage/used items | Steep discounts ($5–$30) | Retail-like, tidy | Weekday afternoons |
| Broadway Boutique | Unique gifts, handmade décor | Clothing or bulk shopping | Mid-range ($10–$50) | Charming, local | Weekends |
| Divine Realm | Collectibles, anime merch | Furniture/clothing | Moderate ($10–$100+) | Geeky, fun | Evenings/weekends |
| Estate Gold & Silver | Coins, vintage jewelry | Home goods/clothes | Varies ($20–$500+) | Niche, historical | Limited hours (check ahead) |
| Sandy’s Furniture | New furniture, delivery service | Used items/small goods | Fair ($200–$1,000+) | Practical, friendly | Weekdays for deals |
| Kaplan’s Furniture | Durable furniture, sales | Vintage/thrifted items | Value prices ($300–$1,500+) | Reliable, no-frills | Holiday sales weekends |
| Goodwill (Midway Blvd) | Everyday clothes, kitchenware | Furniture/electronics | Cheap ($2–$15) | Busy, restocks often | Mornings for new arrivals |
Vintage Vibes
Vintage Vibes is a small but exciting place to check out if you’re into finding unique items. Every time I visit, there’s always something new on the shelves, whether it’s decorations, old-school furniture, or clothing that you don’t usually see at other stores. The space is easy to walk through, with everything placed nicely and not cluttered or tossed around like in some other thrift shops.
Even though the store is small, you can still find all kinds of interesting things. I always end up leaving with something cool, whether it’s a vintage T-shirt or a funky little decoration. It’s a great spot if you want to find something different but don’t want to spend hours searching.
The vibe of Vintage Vibes really lives up to its name. It has a nostalgic, retro feel, but it’s not dusty or crowded, which is something I really appreciate. You can tell that the owners put a lot of thought and care into curating the items they sell. The store has a nice mix of retro styles and vintage items that are well-kept and fun to look at.
If you like retro fashion and accessories, but you don’t want to deal with piles of stuff to dig through, this is the perfect place to visit. It’s not the largest thrift store, but what they do have is always high quality and worth the visit. Every time I stop by, there’s something new to discover, and I never leave empty-handed.
- Best for: Retro-style decor and rare vintage pieces
- Not ideal for: People looking for modern or bulk clothing
- My Top Picks: 1970s glassware, band tees, small framed artwork
- Location:
Located in: Downtown Elyria
Address: 51 East Ave, Elyria, OH 44035
Related: Best Thrift Shops In Hamilton Ohio
New To You Resale Shop
New To You is a resale spot that has the feel of a well-organized closet. When you walk in, the first thing you notice is how clean and neat everything is. The racks are well-arranged, and the store feels like a place where you can actually find what you’re looking for. The staff is friendly, always greeting you with a smile when you walk through the door, which makes the shopping experience better.
I’ve found some great brands here, often for a fraction of the retail price, and the clothing is always in good shape. Whether you’re looking for shirts, dresses, or shoes, there’s always a nice selection to choose from. They even have some home items, so you might find something for your space too.
What’s great about this store is that they mostly focus on consignment, so while the prices are still affordable, you’re getting higher-quality items. The prices reflect the value, but they’re still reasonable enough that you feel like you’re getting a good deal. It’s not a store you want to rush through, though, you’ll want to take your time to really look around.
The atmosphere is relaxed, and it never feels too crowded, which is something I enjoy. If you’re someone who likes to shop carefully and find dependable pieces that will last, this place is a hidden gem for sure.
- Best for: Quality clothing and well-kept resale finds
- Not ideal for: Quick bargain shopping or super cheap prices
- My Top Picks: Cardigans, purses, and clean women’s blouses
- Location:
Located in: Broad Street shopping area
Address: 625 Broad St, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 322-0755
Operating Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday–Friday: 10 AM – 6 PM
Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Shops In Hamilton Ohio
Roxy’s Emporium
Roxy’s Emporium is a unique shop that mixes vintage, boutique, and handmade items in a way that feels different from your usual thrift store. While it’s not the place for basic finds, I’ve come across some amazing upcycled pieces and decorative items that gave my living room a fresh, fun vibe.
The shop has a cozy, colorful feel that makes you want to stay and explore. The owner is always super friendly and welcoming, which makes it feel even more like a special place to visit. It’s definitely a great stop if you’re on the lookout for something artsy or unique to add to your home.
One of the best things about Roxy’s Emporium is the variety of items you can find. From trinkets and jewelry to quirky clothing pieces, there’s always something interesting to look at. I recommend taking your time to explore because each shelf and rack is filled with fun little details.
It’s the kind of shop where you’ll find unique gifts that stand out, but without breaking the bank. It’s not the place to grab your everyday basics, but if you’re after something eye-catching and different, this store definitely delivers.
- Best for: Handmade goods, accessories, and quirky gifts
- Not ideal for: Basic wardrobe staples or kids’ items
- My Top Picks: Statement rings, painted signs, handmade scarves
- Location:
Located in: Middle Ave shopping row
Address: 604 Middle Ave, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 309-0735
Operating Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday–Friday: 11 AM – 6 PM
Saturday: 11 AM – 4 PM
Sunday: Closed
Goodwill
This Goodwill is one of the larger thrift stores in Elyria, making it a go-to option when you’re in the mood for variety. They’ve got long rows of clothes, shelves filled with books, toys, housewares, and even more depending on the day. I’ve had great luck finding name-brand clothing here for a fraction of the cost, especially if you take your time and dig through the racks.
The store is always clean, and the layout is easy to navigate, which makes shopping a lot more pleasant. Plus, the staff does a great job of keeping everything organized, so you don’t have to deal with clutter. You never really know what you’ll find at Goodwill, but that’s part of the fun.
Sometimes they have furniture, or you might come across unopened electronics, craft supplies, or even holiday decorations. The selection changes all the time, so if you’re patient, you’re bound to come across something useful. It’s definitely a great spot for anyone on a budget, whether you’re looking for affordable clothes or trying to furnish your space without spending a lot of money.
- Best for: Affordable clothing, books, and household items
- Not ideal for: Curated or boutique-style thrifting
- My Top Picks: Men’s jackets, ceramic dishes, used puzzles
- Location:
Located in: Near LCCC campus
Address: 502 Abbe Rd N, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 365-7772
Operating Hours:
Sunday: 10 AM – 6 PM
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 8 PM
Discount Fashion Warehouse Elyria
Discount Fashion Warehouse isn’t your typical thrift store, but it’s still a fantastic spot for finding great fashion at unbeatable prices. The store gets overstock from well-known brands and offers it at a fraction of the original price. It’s clean and organized, with a more retail-style feel than a secondhand store, which is perfect if you’re someone who likes shopping in a tidy environment.
I’ve got jeans for under $10 and jackets that looked brand new, which is a steal for the quality you get. Most of the inventory is focused on clothing and shoes, but they also carry a small selection of accessories and bags. The store layout is simple, making it easy to browse, and the dressing rooms are spacious and clean.
There’s no clutter to deal with, so it’s a stress-free shopping experience. If you like the idea of getting brand-new clothes at secondhand prices, Discount Fashion Warehouse is definitely worth checking out.
- Best for: Discount brand-name clothes and clean shopping space
- Not ideal for: Used or vintage items
- My Top Picks: Levi’s jeans, Nike hoodies, fashion sneakers
- Location:
Located in: Midway Blvd plaza
Address: 285 Midway Blvd, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 219-4593
Operating Hours:
Sunday: 11 AM – 7 PM
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 9 PM
Broadway Boutique
Broadway Boutique is a small but inviting shop filled with handmade goods, unique gifts, and vintage-inspired items. It’s not your typical thrift store, but I always stop by when I want something artsy or different. The store is carefully arranged, and you can tell that the owner puts a lot of effort into making the displays look special.
I’ve found everything from cute candles to hand-painted décor and locally made pieces that are perfect for gifting or brightening up my home. It has a welcoming vibe that makes you feel comfortable as soon as you step inside. While the selection is a bit more limited compared to larger thrift stores, it’s the perfect place for anyone looking for unique items.
The inventory changes slowly, so it’s not where you’ll find large shopping hauls, but if you enjoy browsing for special gifts or unique home décor, it’s well worth a visit. The shop also offers in-store pickup and delivery, making it easy if you’re in a rush or need something shipped. Every time I visit, I feel like I’m discovering a new treasure, and it’s nice to support a local, woman-owned business that really cares about the community.
- Best for: Unique gifts, handmade décor, small-batch items
- Not ideal for: Clothing, bulk shopping, or major discounts
- My Top Picks: Soy candles, local art, small seasonal gifts
- Location:
Located in: Downtown Elyria
Address: 390 Broad St, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 522-7416
Operating Hours:
Monday–Wednesday: Closed
Thursday–Saturday: 11 AM – 7 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Related: Best Thrift Stores In Mansfield
Divine Realm
Divine Realm is the perfect spot if you’re into collectibles, anime merch, or gaming-related items. It’s one of those places that stands out when you’re looking for something a little different, whether it’s Funko Pops, classic video games, or detailed figurines. The store is easy to navigate, and I’ve always found it to be clean and well-organized, which makes browsing a pleasant experience.
Prices are reasonable, and the staff is friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to chat about what you’re searching for or to offer recommendations. While it’s not the place for secondhand clothes or furniture, if you’re a fan of pop culture or a collector, Divine Realm is a must-visit.
The shop has so much personality, and you can always find something unique that you won’t see anywhere else in town. Whether you’re hunting for the perfect gift for a fan or looking to add to your own collection, this shop is a great place. It’s one of those places where you’ll leave with something fun that’s hard to find anywhere else.
- Best for: Collectibles, anime figures, and pop culture gifts
- Not ideal for: Clothing, furniture, or housewares
- My Top Picks: Funko Pop selection, trading cards, anime plushies
- Location:
Address: 558 Cleveland St, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (216) 312-6102
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 12 PM – 7 PM
Saturday: 1 PM – 7 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 7 PM
Estate Gold & Silver Exchange
Estate Gold & Silver Exchange is a great spot if you’re looking for valuable items like rare coins, vintage jewelry, and collectibles. Although it’s more of a gold and silver dealer than a traditional thrift store, you can still find some unique secondhand treasures here.
The owner is really knowledgeable about the items he sells and is always happy to talk about the history behind them. It’s not a huge place, but it’s well-organized, and every piece has a story. Whether you’re a collector or just enjoy looking at cool, valuable things, this shop has something interesting to offer.
The shop doesn’t carry typical thrift store items like clothes or furniture, so it’s more of a niche store. Their hours are a bit limited, so it’s a good idea to check before you go. Despite this, I had a great experience there and even picked up a few old coins at a reasonable price.
It’s a place where you might find that perfect collectible or piece of jewelry that’s hard to find anywhere else. While it may not be for everyone, if you have an interest in rare or antique items, Estate Gold & Silver Exchange is definitely worth a visit.
- Best for: Coins, silver, estate jewelry, and collectibles
- Not ideal for: Clothes, home décor, or household items
- My Top Picks: Mercury dimes, silver necklaces, rare finds
- Location:
Address: 230 2nd St, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 323-4258
Operating Hours:
Monday, Tuesday, Thursday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Saturday: 12 PM – 3 PM
Wednesday, Friday, Sunday: Closed
Sandy’s Furniture
Sandy’s Furniture is one of my top choices when I need to update my living room or bedroom without spending too much money. They have a good selection of furniture, from comfy sofas to stylish bedroom sets, and you can often find really great deals on full sets that include everything you need. Every time I’ve been there, the staff is friendly and helpful.
They take the time to answer any questions and help you find what you’re looking for. One of the best things about this store is that they offer delivery, which makes buying a new couch or other large items so much easier. Instead of worrying about hauling it home yourself, they bring it right to your door.
While their prices are a little higher than typical thrift store prices, the furniture is good quality and worth the price. The pieces are sturdy, stylish, and hold up well over time, so you’re really getting your money’s worth. They offer a mix of modern and classic styles, so whether you’re into sleek, contemporary designs or more traditional looks, you’ll find something you like.
I also like that Sandy’s Furniture serves the whole Lorain County area, making it easier for more people to shop here. The store is clean, well-organized, and easy to shop in, which makes the experience enjoyable. It’s not crowded, so you won’t feel rushed, and the staff is always ready to help. Overall, Sandy’s Furniture offers great service, fair prices, and furniture that will last, which is exactly what I want when I’m updating my home.
- Best for: New furniture at fair prices, delivery service
- Not ideal for: Used items, clothing, or smaller resale goods
- My Top Picks: Bedroom sets, reclining sofas, dining tables
- Location:
Address: 422 Lake Ave, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 322-7109
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 7:30 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Kaplan’s Furniture
Kaplan’s Furniture has been around for quite some time, and it’s clear why people keep coming back, it’s dependable, and the furniture feels like it’s made to last. I’ve visited a few times to pick up home essentials like mattresses and sectionals, and I’m always impressed with the quality.
They frequently have sales, and the discounts are often pretty good, especially if you’re looking for a deal on bigger items. One of the things I really appreciate about Kaplan’s is that the staff is helpful without being pushy. I can take my time and browse at my own pace, which makes the shopping experience a lot more relaxed.
While Kaplan’s isn’t a thrift store in the usual sense, it fits right in with the idea of affordable home shopping in Elyria. It’s more of a value furniture store, offering solid pieces that can make a big difference in your home. If you’re looking for something that’s built well and ready to be used right away, it’s a great spot to check out.
You won’t have to wait weeks for delivery like you would with online stores, which is really convenient. It’s a dependable choice when you need quality furniture without the long wait times or high prices.
- Best for: New furniture with fair prices and ongoing sales
- Not ideal for: Vintage finds, used items, or smaller goods
- My Top Picks: Recliners, mattress deals, dining room sets
- Location:
Address: 638 Broad St, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 322-6128
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 10 AM – 6 PM
Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Goodwill Industries of Lorain County
Goodwill on Midway Blvd is my go-to spot whenever I’m in the mood to browse for everyday clothes, housewares, or seasonal décor. The prices are fair, and the store is well-organized, which is a huge plus for a Goodwill. I’ve found a wide range of items here, from jackets to coffee makers.
One thing I like is that they restock often, so even if I don’t find what I’m looking for right away, it’s always worth checking back. I also appreciate that the store is clean and easy to navigate, with clear sections for different types of items, making it simple to find what you need.
If you’re specifically hunting for trendy or name-brand items, it might take a little extra digging. But overall, it’s a reliable stop if you’re looking for basics or budget-friendly finds. The staff is always friendly and helpful, making the shopping experience more pleasant.
I’ve even gotten to know a few of them over time, and they’re always willing to assist when I need help finding something specific. Whether you’re looking to score a deal on everyday items or add a few unique finds to your collection, this Goodwill is definitely worth a visit. Plus, with new items coming in all the time, there’s always something fresh to discover on the racks.
- Best for: Clothing, kitchenware, and budget-friendly home goods
- Not ideal for: Furniture, electronics, or curated selections
- My Top Picks: Jackets, mugs, picture frames
- Location:
Address: 145 Keep Ct, Elyria, OH 44035
Contact No: (440) 244-3174
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 8 AM – 4:30 PM
Saturday & Sunday: Closed
Frequently Asked Questions
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Elyria is full of surprises, and each store has its own charm. Whether you’re after budget finds, vintage pieces, or gently used furniture, there’s a spot in town that’s just right for you. I hope this list helps you find your next great buy and makes planning your shopping trip more fun and easier. Happy thrifting!
