If you enjoy finding good deals and cool secondhand items, you’ll love shopping at the best thrift stores in Lafayette. These stores have all kinds of things like clothes, furniture, books, toys, and more. Many places also help the community or support good causes. You don’t have to spend a lot of money to find something nice or useful. Thrift shopping in Lafayette can be fun, easy, and full of surprises.
Lafayette has a mix of thrift shops, vintage stores, and consignment places. Some stores feel like little boutiques, while others are big and packed with stuff. Whether you’re looking for clothes for yourself, things for your home, or items for your kids, there’s a shop for everyone. You can even find handmade items or rare collectibles. This guide will help you discover some of the top places to check out.
Best Thrift Shops in Lafayette – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Millie’s Thrift Store | Cheap clothes & home items | Fancy vintage/designer items | Very affordable | Friendly, community-focused | Weekday mornings |
| Trinity Life Ministry Outlet | Budget home goods & clothes | High-end brands | Super low prices | Simple, mission-driven | Early afternoon |
| Sell It Here | Treasure hunting & variety | Quick shopping | Fair prices | Huge, warehouse-style | Weekends (more booths open) |
| Reclaimed Hope | Handmade gifts & recycled items | Clothes or furniture | Moderate | Cozy, artsy | Weekday afternoons |
| Vintage Vault | Retro fashion & video games | Modern clothes | Good deals | Fun, nostalgic | Evenings (coolest finds) |
| Salvation Army | Budget basics & helping others | High-end furniture | Cheap to moderate | Busy, practical | Weekday mornings |
| Simply Chic Lafayette | Stylish women’s fashion | Men’s/kids’ clothes | Moderate | Boutique-like | Weekday afternoons |
| Twice As Nice | Like-new women’s clothes | Bargain hunting | Slightly higher | Bright, organized | Weekday mornings |
| Lafayette Habitat ReStore | Furniture & home improvement | Clothing | Great deals | Practical, DIY-friendly | Saturday mornings |
| Purdue Surplus Store | Office supplies & tech gear | Home décor | Very affordable | Quiet, no-frills | Weekday afternoons |
| Amused Clothing | Streetwear & skate gear | Formal/home items | Fair prices | Edgy, youthful | Weekends |
| Rita’s Closet | Women’s boutique-style fashion | Men’s items | Moderate | Chic, calm | Weekday afternoons |
| Once Upon A Child | Kids’ clothes & toys | Adult items | Budget-friendly | Neat, family-friendly | Weekday mornings |
Millie’s Thrift Store
Millie’s Thrift Store is a great place to shop if you like finding nice things at low prices. The people who work here are always friendly and helpful. The store is clean, easy to walk around, and full of different items. You can find clothes, home items, decorations, and even books here. I really like how they set up the store, everything is easy to see, and the prices are fair.
What makes Millie’s special is that it helps people in the Lafayette community. When you shop here, your money goes to a good cause. That’s why I think it’s one of the top rated thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana. I’ve bought holiday decorations and good jeans here without spending too much. It’s one of those places that makes you feel good both while shopping and after.
- Best for: Cheap clothes and house items
- Not ideal for: Fancy vintage or designer things
- My top picks: Women’s jeans, kids’ books, home décor
- Location details:
📍 101 Plaza Ln, Lafayette, IN 47909
📞 (765) 607-4899
🕒 Mon–Thu 10 AM–6:30 PM, Fri 10 AM–6:30 PM, Sat 9 AM–5 PM, Sun Closed
Trinity Life Ministry Lafayette Outlet Store
Trinity Life Ministry Outlet Store is a big thrift shop with lots of choices. The store is clean and the items are mostly well organized. They sell clothes, shoes, kitchen stuff, and even furniture. The prices are very low, and that helps if you are shopping on a tight budget. The staff is kind most of the time, and they care about the people they help.
This store is part of a group that helps men recover from addiction, so your money supports a good mission. Even if it’s not the fanciest store, it has a lot to offer. I’ve found shoes and useful things for my kitchen that cost way less than in regular stores. If you want good deals and like helping others, this is one of the better thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana to check out.
- Best for: Low-cost home goods and clothes
- Not ideal for: High-end brands or stylish layouts
- My top picks: Kitchen tools, men’s clothes, basic furniture
- Location details:
📍 2324 Shoshone Ct, Lafayette, IN 47904
📞 (765) 742-1060
🕒 Mon–Fri 9 AM–6 PM, Sat 9 AM–5 PM, Sun Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Muncie
Sell It Here
Sell It Here is one of the biggest resale stores I’ve ever been to. It’s huge, like a warehouse, with hundreds of booths filled with different things. You can find old furniture, books, clothes, kitchen items, and even handmade things. It feels like a big market, and every booth has something different. It’s one of those places where you can spend hours just looking around.
This store is definitely one of the top 10 thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana. Every time I go, I find something cool, like a wood chair or old glassware. They also have a little café inside with snacks that are good for people who eat low sugar or keto. The prices are fair, and it’s a fun place to visit if you like hunting for special items.
- Best for: Treasure hunting and variety
- Not ideal for: Quick shopping or brand-name clothes
- My top picks: Vintage furniture, glassware, keto snacks
- Location details:
📍 3805 Fortune Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 464-6519
🕒 Mon–Sat 10 AM–6 PM, Sun 12–5 PM
Reclaimed Hope
Reclaimed Hope is a small thrift store inside the Northend Community Center. It’s not very big, but it has a lot of cute items. They sell jewelry, wall décor, and some small home goods. Most of the things here are made from recycled materials, which I think is really cool. The store is peaceful and the people working there are very nice.
When you shop here, you are also helping women in need. This makes it one of the most caring second hand stores in Lafayette, Indiana. I found a pretty necklace and a small picture frame that I love. It’s not the place for big furniture or lots of clothes, but if you want something pretty and handmade, this store is worth a visit.
- Best for: Cute gifts and recycled items
- Not ideal for: Clothes shopping or furniture
- My top picks: Jewelry, wall art, small antiques
- Location details:
📍 2000 Elmwood Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904
📞 (765) 449-3711
🕒 Wed–Fri 9 AM–5 PM, Sat 9 AM–5 PM, Sun–Tue Closed
Vintage Vault
Vintage Vault is the place to go if you like old-school clothes and cool video games. The store looks fun from the moment you walk in. They have racks full of clothes from the 80s and 90s, like sports jackets, old jeans, and graphic t-shirts. They also buy and trade, so you can bring stuff from home to sell or swap. The people who work here are friendly and love what they do.
This store is one of the best vintage thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana for finding retro stuff. I picked up a cool jacket and an old Game Boy game that reminded me of my childhood. The prices are good and the vibe is relaxed. If you like vintage clothes and fun old games, you’ll love this place.
- Best for: Vintage fashion and gaming
- Not ideal for: Modern clothes or house items
- My top picks: Retro jackets, vintage games, sportswear
- Location details:
📍 525 Wabash Ave, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 418-7449
🕒 Mon–Sat 12–10 PM, Sun 12–9 PM
The Salvation Army Family Store
The Salvation Army Family Store is a big thrift shop with lots of useful things. You can find clothes, shoes, furniture, kitchen items, and more. The prices are usually fair, and I like how the staff is always friendly and ready to help. It’s a good place to look around if you need a couch or a few pieces of clothing but don’t want to spend too much.
This store also supports a really important cause. When you buy something, your money goes to help people in recovery. That makes me feel good about shopping here. Some of the furniture can be expensive and not in great shape, but overall, it’s still one of the top rated thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana if you want to support a mission while shopping.
- Best for: Shopping on a budget while helping others
- Not ideal for: Fancy or high-end furniture
- My top picks: Coats, shoes, small household items
- Location details:
📍 2121 Sagamore Pkwy S, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 446-2191
🕒 Mon–Sat 9 AM–9 PM, Sun Closed
Simply Chic Lafayette
Simply Chic Lafayette is a resale shop just for women, and it’s a really fun place to shop. The clothes here are modern and stylish, and everything looks clean and nicely set up. I like how they only accept gently used items, so everything still feels new. You can also sell your own clothes and get cash the same day, which is super helpful.
This is one of the best resale stores Lafayette, Indiana has if you want to dress well without spending a lot. The staff is sweet and will help you find your size or show you the best deals. I found a cute purse and a pair of brand-name flats for way less than what I’d pay at a mall. If you love fashion and savings, this is the place.
- Best for: Stylish women’s fashion on a budget
- Not ideal for: Men’s or kids’ clothes
- My top picks: Shoes, handbags, business-casual outfits
- Location details:
📍 200 Farabee Dr N, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 464-6099
🕒 Mon–Sat 10 AM–7 PM, Sun 12–6 PM
Twice As Nice Ladies Consignment Boutique
Twice As Nice is a bright and clean consignment shop with a cozy feel. The clothes and accessories are in really good shape, almost like new. Everything is well organized, and you don’t have to dig through a mess to find something nice. The people working here are super friendly and know a lot about fashion.
If you’re looking for gently worn clothing that still feels fresh and fun, this is one of the best consignment shops in Lafayette, Indiana. The prices are a bit higher than regular thrift stores, but still lower than buying new. I found a cute blouse and a necklace that I wear all the time. It’s a great stop if you like clean stores with nice things.
- Best for: Like-new women’s clothes and friendly service
- Not ideal for: Big furniture or bargain hunting
- My top picks: Dresses, scarves, jewelry
- Location details:
📍 738 S Earl Ave, Lafayette, IN 47904
📞 (765) 448-4618
🕒 Mon–Fri 10 AM–5 PM, Sat 10 AM–4 PM, Sun Closed
Lafayette Habitat ReStore
Habitat ReStore is the spot if you’re fixing up your home or apartment. It has all kinds of household items like tools, sinks, chairs, and shelves. Some of the furniture looks brand new, and the prices are often way lower than a regular store. I even saw two armchairs for under $10!
If you’re on a budget and doing some home updates, this is one of the best furniture thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana. Not everything is cheap, but most of it is a great deal. I like how they also deliver if you buy something big. It’s a store that helps people and offers great finds.
- Best for: Furniture and home improvement items
- Not ideal for: Clothes or fashion
- My top picks: Chairs, hardware, lamps
- Location details:
📍 3815 Fortune Dr, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 423-2585
🕒 Tue & Thu 10 AM–6 PM, Wed & Fri 10 AM–5 PM, Sat 9 AM–4 PM, Sun & Mon Closed
Purdue University Surplus Store
The Purdue Surplus Store is a hidden gem in West Lafayette. It sells used items from the university, like desks, chairs, monitors, keyboards, and even books. Everything is very clean and works well. Some of the stuff still looks brand new. It’s quiet and easy to shop, and the staff is helpful if you have questions.
It’s one of the more unique second hand stores in Lafayette, Indiana because it’s focused on office and tech gear. I got a sturdy office chair and a whiteboard for my home office at a great price. If you’re setting up a workspace or just love digging through old tech, this is the place to go.
- Best for: Office supplies and used tech gear
- Not ideal for: Clothing or home decor
- My top picks: Chairs, monitors, filing cabinets
- Location details:
📍 698 Ahlers Dr, West Lafayette, IN 47907
📞 (765) 496-2222
🕒 Mon–Fri 12–4 PM, Sat–Sun Closed
Amused Clothing
Amused Clothing is a fun and different kind of thrift shop in Lafayette. When I walked in, I saw all kinds of cool things like t-shirts, hats, skateboards, and even stuff like smoking accessories. The store has a chill vibe, and the workers are really nice and friendly. They are happy to help you if you have questions. The prices are good, and there’s a lot to look through. It’s a good place if you like streetwear or want to find something unique.
Even though the store has a lot of items, it’s still pretty organized. I liked that every time I looked around, I saw something new. They have clothes, gear, and little items that are hard to find in other places. If you’re into bold or fun styles, you’ll enjoy shopping here. It’s one of the coolest thrift shops Lafayette, Indiana has to offer for younger styles and funky finds.
- Best for: streetwear, skateboards, fun accessories
- Not ideal for: home items or formal clothes
- My top picks: graphic tees, snapback hats, and longboards
- Location details:
📍 3023 South St, Lafayette, IN 47904
📞 (765) 449-8733
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–7 PM | Sun: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Columbus Indiana
Rita’s Closet
Rita’s Closet is a really nice and clean secondhand store. It feels more like a cute little boutique. When I visited, I saw a lot of pretty clothes, shoes, and purses. Everything looked new or very gently used. They have good brands too, and the prices were not high. The shop is calm and cozy, and the people working there are kind and helpful. They keep everything neat and easy to look through.
This store is great if you like fashion but don’t want to spend a lot of money. They have stylish items, and it doesn’t feel messy or crowded. You can find good outfits without much digging. It’s one of the best consignment shops in Lafayette, Indiana for women who want to shop for cute clothes and bags.
- Best for: women’s clothing, purses, and stylish finds
- Not ideal for: men’s clothes or furniture
- My top picks: name-brand blouses, handbags, boots
- Location details:
📍 3107 Builder Dr Suite 7, Lafayette, IN 47909
🕒 Mon–Wed: 11 AM–7 PM | Thu–Sat: 11 AM–8 PM | Sun: Closed
Once Upon A Child
Once Upon A Child is a very good thrift store for parents with kids. It’s one of the most trusted thrift stores in Lafayette, Indiana for baby and children’s items. When I went, the store was full of clothes, shoes, toys, books, and baby gear like strollers and car seats. Everything looked clean and in good shape. The items were sorted by size, so it was easy to find what I needed. The staff were kind and helped me find what I was looking for.
The store adds new items all the time, so there’s always something different. You can also bring your child’s old clothes and sell them to the store. That way, you can earn a little money or get store credit. It’s a good way to shop smart and save money. If you’re a parent, this place is a must-visit.
- Best for: baby clothes, kids’ shoes, and toys
- Not ideal for: adult clothing or furniture
- My top picks: onesies, baby shoes, and toddler toys
- Location details:
📍 124 Farabee Dr N, Lafayette, IN 47905
📞 (765) 449-1299
🕒 Mon–Sat: 9 AM–8 PM | Sun: 11 AM–6 PM
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Lafayette is a great way to save money and find special items. Whether you need clothes, furniture, kids’ things, or something unique, there’s always a store that has what you’re looking for. Each shop has its own style and charm, so it’s fun to try different ones. Many of these stores also support good causes, which makes your shopping even more meaningful. So take your time, explore, and enjoy finding rare items across the city!
