The best thrift stores in Findlay offer all kinds of secondhand deals, from used clothes and furniture to baby gear, home goods, and more. Whether you’re hunting for brand-name fashion on a budget, need furniture for your place, or want to pick up tools or electronics for less, Findlay has plenty of local shops worth checking out. Some stores are perfect for everyday savings, while others help support good causes in the community. As a local thrift shopper, I’ve had a chance to visit many of these spots and can share what each one is really like.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through some of my favorite thrift, consignment, discount, and pawn shops across Findlay. Each store has its own vibe and specialty, so there’s something for everyone. I’ll let you know what they’re best for, what they’re not ideal for, and highlight a few top finds I personally recommend. Plus, I’ve included all the location details to make your shopping trip easier. Let’s take a look at what Findlay has to offer!
Best Thrift Shops in Findlay – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Transformations Thrift Store | Unique finds, vintage décor | High-end designer items | Budget-friendly | Calm, welcoming | Weekday mornings |
| Nearly New Shop | Quality clothing, community support | Late-night shopping | Fair prices | Clean, boutique-like | Tuesday–Thursday mornings |
| Style Encore | Trendy women’s fashion | Men’s clothing or home goods | Moderate | Organized, stylish | Weekday afternoons |
| Habitat for Humanity ReStore | Furniture, DIY home projects | Clothing or small décor | Great deals | Spacious, purposeful | Weekends for new stock |
| Salvation Army Thrift Store | Budget basics, variety | Luxury brands | Very affordable | Busy, lively | Weekday mornings for sales |
| Home Once More | Affordable home décor | Clothing or furniture | Low to moderate | Cozy, charming | Seasonal sales days |
| Goodwill Findlay | Everyday clothing, household items | Rare vintage finds | Bargain prices | Neat, spacious | Weekday afternoons |
| Thistle Exchange | Handmade gifts, rustic décor | Big-ticket furniture | Reasonable | Peaceful, curated | Weekday afternoons |
| Plato’s Closet | Brand-name teen/young adult fashion | Vintage or formal wear | Slightly higher | Trendy, upbeat | Weekends for new arrivals |
| Sparrows to Lilies | Boutique women’s clothing | Bulk deals or men’s items | Moderate | Quiet, intentional | Weekday mornings |
| Gabe’s | Bargain clothing, home goods | Designer labels | Super cheap | Treasure-hunt vibe | Weekday evenings |
| Pack Rats Pawn Shop | Tools, electronics, instruments | Brand-new high-end goods | Negotiable | Friendly, no-frills | Weekday afternoons |
| Once Upon A Child | Kids’ clothes, toys, baby gear | Non-kids’ items | Great discounts | Family-friendly | Weekday mornings |
| City Mission of Findlay | Thrifting with a cause | High-end or new items | Very low | Community-focused | Anytime (open 24/7) |
Style Encore
Style Encore is a must-visit spot for anyone in Findlay looking to update their wardrobe with trendy, gently used clothing. The store is packed with a wide variety of women’s apparel, shoes, and accessories that cater to different tastes and styles. As soon as you walk in, you’ll notice how well-organized everything is, making it easy to browse through the racks and find exactly what you’re looking for.
Many shoppers praise the store for its stylish selections and affordable prices, making it the perfect place to score a chic outfit without blowing your budget. From casual pieces to dressier items, there’s something here for every fashion lover. What truly sets Style Encore apart is its commitment to sustainability. The store’s rotating inventory ensures that every visit brings new options, keeping things fresh and exciting for repeat customers.
The staff is always ready to help, offering friendly advice and assisting shoppers in finding the right outfit for any occasion. Whether you’re in need of a casual day look or something for a more formal event, Style Encore has it all. It’s the place to go for fashionable pieces that are both kind to your wallet and the planet. If you love fashion and want to shop sustainably, Style Encore is the perfect store for you.
- Best For: Trendy women’s fashion, organized shopping experience, and sustainable choices.
- Not Ideal For: Those seeking men’s clothing or home goods.
- My Top Picks: Designer handbags, stylish dresses, and seasonal footwear.
Location Details:
- Address: 1821 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 422-4600
- Hours: Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–8 PM; Sunday: 12 PM–6 PM
Transformations Thrift Store
Transformations Thrift Store is one of the best thrift stores in Findlay, offering a calm and welcoming environment for anyone who enjoys thrifting. From the moment I walked in, I noticed how tidy and well-organized everything was, which immediately made me feel at ease.
The store is neatly arranged, with sections for clothing, shoes, small furniture, and home decor, making it easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed. I was able to find items quickly, and the staff was super friendly and approachable. They were always nearby, ready to assist with anything I needed, whether it was offering a suggestion or helping me locate an item.
It’s a great spot for anyone looking for quality items at a fair price, and the peaceful atmosphere makes shopping here a pleasure. What truly sets Transformations Thrift Store apart is its commitment to giving back to the community. Not only do they regularly refresh their inventory, but they also support local causes, which gives an added layer of satisfaction to every purchase.
Each time I visit, I notice new items on the shelves, which makes it fun to come back and see what’s different. The store is consistently clean and well-organized, which makes the shopping experience feel even more enjoyable. On my last trip, I found a set of vintage kitchen items that I couldn’t pass up, as well as a pair of gently used boots.
Despite being a smaller store, it’s always packed with great finds and a sense of community. Whether you’re an experienced thrifter or new to the scene, Transformations is definitely a must-visit spot in Findlay for anyone looking for bargains with a purpose.
- Best For: Unique finds, friendly staff, and a welcoming atmosphere.
- Not Ideal For: Those seeking high-end designer items.
- My Top Picks: Vintage home decor, gently used clothing, and eclectic accessories.
Location Details:
- Address: 330 Walnut St, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (567) 250-9129
- Hours: Tuesday–Thursday: 10 AM–5 PM; Friday: 9 AM–5 PM; Saturday: 9 AM–2 PM; Closed Sunday & Monday
Nearly New Shop
Nearly New Shop is one of the best thrift stores in Findlay, offering a carefully curated collection of gently used items. The store is run by passionate volunteers who truly care about providing a positive experience for shoppers. When I visited, I was impressed by how well-organized the store is.
Each section, from clothing to home goods, was easy to navigate, making my shopping trip feel smooth and enjoyable. The boutique section stood out with stylish clothing and accessories that were both trendy and affordable. It’s clear that a lot of thought goes into the selection, making Nearly New Shop a perfect destination for anyone looking for high-quality items without the high price tag.
What makes Nearly New Shop stand out is its strong commitment to supporting the community. The proceeds from the store go directly to the Blanchard Valley Health System, which adds a meaningful purpose to every purchase. Regular visitors often mention how clean and inviting the store is, along with the warm and friendly staff who are always ready to lend a hand.
While the store has limited hours, it’s definitely worth the visit if you’re looking for great deals and a chance to give back. Whether you’re on the hunt for a new outfit or something special for your home, Nearly New Shop is a must-visit in Findlay for those who appreciate quality and community impact.
- Best For: Quality clothing, community-driven shopping, and supporting a good cause.
- Not Ideal For: Late evening shoppers due to limited hours.
- My Top Picks: Boutique clothing, vintage books, and unique jewelry pieces.
Location Details:
- Address: 306 Lima Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 423-4335
- Hours: Tuesday–Thursday: 10 AM–4 PM; Saturday: 10 AM–1 PM; Closed Sunday, Monday, and Friday
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Lancaster Ohio
Home Once More
Home Once More is a cozy little shop with a great selection of home décor and household items at affordable prices. Located in Eastowne Plaza, it’s easy to stop by while you’re already shopping in the area. The store has a wide variety of items, including picture frames, lamps, seasonal decorations, and kitchenware.
I’ve found some amazing holiday décor and stylish wall art here at prices much lower than what you’d find in regular stores. It’s a perfect place if you want to refresh your living space without spending a lot of money. The store is always clean and well-organized, making it a pleasant place to shop. It’s fun to browse around and see what’s new, whether you’re looking to update a room or just want to add a few new pieces to your home.
They often have markdowns and special sales, especially near the end of a season when items change. This is a great place to visit if you’re decorating on a budget because you can find quality items at great prices. Home Once More is a hidden gem for anyone looking to make their home feel fresh and stylish without spending too much.
- Best for: Affordable home décor and gifts.
- Not ideal for: Clothing or furniture shoppers.
- My Top Picks: Decorative signs, table runners, and seasonal wreaths.
- Location Details:
- Located in: Eastowne Plaza
- Address: 1949 Tiffin Ave #4, Findlay, OH 45840
- Contact No: (419) 422-1222
- Operating Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 8 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 6 PM
Habitat for Humanity ReStore
Habitat for Humanity ReStore is an excellent place to shop for anyone looking to furnish their home while sticking to a budget. With a wide selection of furniture, appliances, and home improvement items, there’s something for everyone. The inventory is constantly changing, so every visit offers new finds, making it feel like a treasure hunt.
Shoppers appreciate the variety and the ability to get great deals on high-quality items. Best of all, proceeds from every purchase go toward supporting Habitat for Humanity’s mission, which helps build homes for those in need, giving your shopping experience an added sense of purpose. The store itself is spacious and well-organized, making it easy to browse through the different sections and find exactly what you’re looking for.
The staff is always friendly and available to help, ensuring a pleasant shopping experience. While some items might show signs of wear, many are in excellent condition and ready to be put to use in your home. DIY enthusiasts especially love this spot, as there are plenty of materials and furniture pieces that can be refurbished or upcycled.
With regular sales and promotions, the deals at Habitat for Humanity ReStore keep getting better. It’s a go-to destination for anyone looking to enhance their living space affordably while contributing to a good cause.
- Best For: Affordable home furnishings, supporting a good cause, and unique finds.
- Not Ideal For: Those seeking brand-new items or specific product models.
- My Top Picks: Solid wood furniture, home improvement materials, and vintage decor.
Location Details:
- Address: 1200 Commerce Pkwy, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 429-1400
- Hours: Tuesday–Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM; Closed Sunday & Monday
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
The Salvation Army Thrift Store is a well-known and loved store in the Findlay community. It offers a large variety of second-hand items at great prices. Whether you’re looking for clothing, home goods, or furniture, you’ll find affordable options here. The store is well-organized, making it easy to find what you’re looking for.
The staff is always friendly and helpful, which makes shopping there a pleasant experience. On top of that, every purchase you make supports The Salvation Army’s mission to help people in need, so you can feel good about your shopping. What makes this store even better are the regular sales, like color-tag promotions, where you can grab even more great deals.
The inventory is updated often, so every visit brings something new to check out. While you might need to spend a little time searching for the perfect item, the chance of finding something unique makes it worth it. Whether you need everyday items or are just in the mood to look for something special, The Salvation Army Thrift Store is a great place to visit. It’s a spot where you can find good deals while also supporting a cause that helps others.
- Best For: Budget-friendly shopping, diverse inventory, and supporting charitable initiatives.
- Not Ideal For: Those seeking high-end or specialty items.
- My Top Picks: Casual clothing, kitchenware, and children’s toys.
Location Details:
- Address: 509 N Main St, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (800) 728-7825
- Hours: Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–7 PM; Closed Sunday
Goodwill Findlay
This Goodwill location in Eastowne Plaza is a secret spot, much bigger on the inside than it appears from the outside. The store is clean, tidy, and well-organized, which makes shopping here enjoyable. They carry a wide selection of gently used items, including clothes for men, women, and children, shoes, books, household items, and even a few furniture pieces.
I find that it’s one of my go-to stops when I’m in the area because there’s always something new to look at. Whether you’re in the mood to browse clothing or find a unique household item, you can always count on finding something useful. The staff is friendly and helpful, which adds to the pleasant experience. You can really take your time here and enjoy hunting for great deals.
One thing that stands out to me about this Goodwill is how well-organized the shelves and racks are. It’s easy to find what you’re looking for, and it’s not cluttered, which can make shopping feel more relaxing. Although you might not always find big brand names, the pricing is always affordable and fair, which makes up for it.
I love that they frequently have weekly color tag sales, so if you time your visit right, you can save even more. They also rotate the items pretty quickly, so you’ll always find something fresh every time you stop by. This Goodwill is a reliable place to find great deals, and it’s well worth a visit if you’re looking to score some budget-friendly treasures. Whether you’re a seasoned thrifter or a beginner, there’s always something here that’ll catch your eye.
- Best for: Basic clothing and general thrift shopping.
- Not ideal for: Vintage lovers or rare finds.
- My Top Picks: Men’s jeans, drinkware, and kids’ toys.
- Location Details:
- Located in: Eastowne Plaza
- Address: 1925 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Contact No: (419) 424-1361
- Operating Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 8 PM
- Sunday: 10 AM – 6 PM
Thistle Exchange
Thistle Exchange is a lovely little store that sits just outside the busy shopping areas, making it a peaceful spot to visit. What I love about it is that everything feels unique and special, yet it’s all priced very reasonably. The store offers a wide variety of home goods, from rustic wooden signs to handmade crafts, and secondhand décor that’s perfect for adding charm to any room.
If you’re someone who enjoys decorating or taking on DIY projects, you’ll find plenty of inspiration here. It’s the kind of place where you can pick up items that are both stylish and affordable, giving your home a boutique look without the high price tag. The best part is, the inventory changes often, so there’s always something new to discover each time you visit.
Even though Thistle Exchange is smaller than some other stores in the area, it makes up for it with its peaceful atmosphere and thoughtful setup. Everything is displayed in an organized, gallery-like way that makes it easy to enjoy browsing without feeling rushed. I often find myself stopping by just to check out their selection of new wall art or small, unique gifts.
The store has a calming vibe, and the friendly staff makes it even more welcoming. You’ll find a little bit of everything here, whether you’re on the hunt for a new piece of décor or searching for the perfect gift. Thistle Exchange is a great place for anyone who loves unique finds and a relaxing shopping experience.
- Best for: Unique home décor and gift items.
- Not ideal for: Those looking for clothing or large furniture.
- My Top Picks: Framed prints, handmade candles, and baskets.
- Location Details:
- Address: 11300 County Rd 99, Findlay, OH 45840
- Contact No: (419) 619-5635
- Operating Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Plato’s Closet
Plato’s Closet is a great spot for anyone looking for trendy, gently used clothing, especially if you’re a teen or young adult. The store is full of current styles, and you’ll find plenty of popular brands like Nike, Adidas, American Eagle, and more. I really like how the store organizes everything by size and clothing type, making it super easy to quickly find what you need without wasting time.
Whether you’re searching for athletic wear, casual outfits, or something to wear to a party, it’s a great place to check out the latest fashion trends on a budget. While the prices at Plato’s Closet are higher than your typical thrift store, they are still a lot more affordable than buying new clothes.
I’ve managed to snag some fantastic deals, especially when I check out their clearance racks, where I’ve found quality denim for under $10. It’s not the best spot for vintage pieces or simple basics, but if you’re into name-brand clothes, it’s definitely worth a visit. It’s a great way to refresh your wardrobe without breaking the bank, and you can find some really trendy items that fit your personal style.
- Best for: Brand-name clothing for teens and young adults.
- Not ideal for: Vintage shoppers or those looking for home items.
- My Top Picks: Hoodies, athletic wear, and sneakers.
- Location Details:
- Located in: Market Square Shopping Center
- Address: 1829 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Contact No: (419) 422-0700
- Operating Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 9 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 6 PM
Sparrows to Lilies
Sparrows to Lilies is a charming little thrift shop that really stands out for its curated selection of high-quality secondhand clothing. The store has a boutique-style vibe, focusing on well-maintained pieces rather than a large quantity of items. When you walk in, you’re greeted with neatly organized racks and clean displays, making it easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed.
The atmosphere is calm and relaxing, which makes it a pleasant stop if you’re looking for something specific or just want to enjoy a slower, more intentional shopping experience. The store’s inventory mostly features women’s clothing and accessories, and everything I’ve found here has been in great shape.
While I don’t usually leave with a big shopping haul, I always know I can find one or two great pieces. Whether you’re after a stylish new outfit or just a unique accessory to complement your wardrobe, Sparrows to Lilies is a wonderful local stop. It’s a place where you can find quality items without the rush or clutter you might experience at bigger thrift stores.
- Best for: Carefully selected women’s clothing.
- Not ideal for: Furniture or bargain hunters looking for bulk deals.
- My Top Picks: Blouses, handbags, and scarves.
- Location Details:
- Address: 624 S Main St, Findlay, OH 45840
- Contact No: Not listed
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: 12 PM – 5 PM
- Tuesday, Thursday–Friday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Wednesday: 1 PM – 5 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM – 3 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Gabe’s
Gabe’s is a hidden gem for anyone who loves a good bargain. It’s one of those stores where you can easily lose track of time while wandering through its aisles. They offer an extensive range of items, from clothing and shoes to home décor and furniture. What’s great is that the store is well-organized, making it easy to find what you’re looking for without feeling overwhelmed.
Whether you’re shopping for a new outfit, kitchen gadgets, or a comfy couch, there’s something for everyone. The staff is friendly and always ready to help, whether you’re looking for a specific size or just want some advice on what to pick. It’s a perfect place for people who like to discover new things every time they visit.
What really makes Gabe’s stand out is how frequently the inventory changes. This means each visit offers something different, and there’s always the possibility of finding great new deals. Whether you’re on the hunt for a brand-new pair of shoes or a unique piece of home décor, you’re sure to find something high-quality at a much lower price than you’d pay at regular retail stores.
You can even find popular brands at a fraction of the cost, making it a top spot for anyone looking to save money while still getting great products. Gabe’s truly offers something for everyone, whether you’re shopping for yourself or looking for gifts, and the friendly atmosphere makes it an enjoyable experience every time.
- Best for: Bargain hunters looking for a variety of items, including clothing, home goods, and furniture. If you love finding great deals on brand-name items, Gabe’s is the place to be.
- Not ideal for: Those looking for high-end or designer items, as the store mainly carries more affordable, mass-market brands.
- My Top Picks:
- Clothing section, Home décor, Furniture
Location Details:
- Address: 1981 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 423-5985
- Hours:
- Monday–Thursday: 9 AM–10 PM
- Friday–Saturday: 9 AM–11 PM
- Sunday: 9 AM–10 PM
Pack Rats Pawn Shop
Pack Rats Pawn Shop is a great spot for finding interesting items at reasonable prices. The store has a wide range of products, including electronics, musical instruments, and tools. Many shoppers enjoy the variety and often come back to see what new items are in stock.
The staff is friendly and always happy to help, whether you’re looking for something specific or just exploring the shelves. It’s easy to find items in good condition here, and the store is well-organized, which makes browsing a breeze. Pack Rats is not just a place to buy or sell, but also a spot where you can stumble upon something truly unique.
One of the best things about Pack Rats is the fair pricing. You can find great deals on items that are in good shape, making it perfect for bargain hunters. They also offer items that you wouldn’t typically find in a regular store, so it’s a great place to get something special. If you’re someone who enjoys checking out local pawn shops for unique items, this one is worth a visit.
The store’s clean and welcoming vibe makes it a pleasant place to shop, and you can spend some time looking around without feeling rushed. Whether you’re on the hunt for electronics or just curious to see what’s new, Pack Rats Pawn Shop is a spot you won’t want to miss.
- Best for: Finding unique items like electronics, musical instruments, and tools at affordable prices. It’s also a great place if you enjoy browsing for something out of the ordinary.
- Not ideal for: People looking for brand-new, high-end products or designer goods.
- My Top Picks:
- Tools: If you’re a DIYer, Pack Rats has a solid range of tools to check out.
- Musical instruments: A great selection for anyone interested in starting or adding to their collection.
- Electronics: Affordable and well-priced options for gadgets.
Location Details:
- Address: 10205 US-224, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (567) 301-2018
- Hours:
- Monday: 12 PM–5 PM
- Tuesday–Friday: 10 AM–5 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Once Upon A Child
Once Upon A Child is a fantastic stop for parents looking to save money while finding quality items for their children. The store has a large selection of gently used clothing, toys, and baby gear, which makes it a one-stop shop for all things kids. Parents love the wide variety of clothes, from everyday wear to special occasion outfits, and everything is in great condition.
The store is organized, clean, and easy to explore, making it stress-free to find exactly what you need. The friendly staff is always ready to help you find what you’re looking for, whether it’s a new outfit for your toddler or a secondhand stroller. Many parents appreciate that they can purchase top-quality items without spending a fortune.
Beyond clothing, Once Upon A Child also carries a variety of toys and baby gear, which is perfect for growing families. It’s an ideal place to find gently used items that would otherwise cost a lot more when bought new. The store frequently updates its inventory, so each visit offers fresh options to choose from.
Plus, they offer a convenient buy-sell-trade option, where you can trade in your child’s gently used items for store credit or cash. Once Upon A Child helps parents save money while still getting the essentials for their little ones, making it a must-visit store.
- Best for: Affordable children’s clothing, toys, and baby equipment. It’s perfect for parents looking to save money while providing quality items for their kids.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for brand-new, high-end or designer children’s goods.
- My Top Picks:
- Toys: A wide variety of toys, from books to interactive playthings for all ages.
- Gently used baby gear: Car seats, strollers, and high chairs in great condition.
- Clothing: Affordable and stylish outfits for babies and toddlers.
Location Details:
- Address: 1825 Tiffin Ave, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 422-0400
- Hours:
- Monday–Saturday: 9:30 AM–8 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM–6 PM
City Mission of Findlay
City Mission of Findlay is a wonderful thrift store that goes beyond offering great deals – it’s deeply involved in supporting the community. The store carries a variety of items, including clothing, household goods, and small furniture, all at affordable prices. What sets it apart is that the proceeds from every purchase go directly to the City Mission’s programs, which provide shelter, food, and other vital services to those in need.
Many shoppers appreciate the sense of giving back to the community with every item they buy. The store is bright, clean, and well-organized, making it easy to browse and find hidden gems. It’s not just a place to shop, but also an opportunity to contribute to a cause that makes a real difference in the lives of people facing hardships.
Customers love the variety of items available, from everyday essentials to special finds. Whether you’re searching for a new winter coat or a set of dishes for your kitchen, City Mission of Findlay offers a wide range of gently used items to meet your needs. The staff is always friendly and helpful, and they’re happy to assist you in finding exactly what you’re looking for.
Shopping here not only feels good because of the great deals, but it also feels good knowing that you’re helping someone in need. The store updates its inventory frequently, so every visit is an opportunity to find something new. It’s a go-to spot for bargain hunters who also want to give back to their community.
- Best for: Finding affordable items while supporting a meaningful cause. Great for those looking for clothing, home goods, and small furniture.
- Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking new or high-end brand items.
- My Top Picks:
- Small furniture: Well-priced furniture pieces that are in good condition.
- Gently used clothing: Affordable, quality clothes for all ages.
- Household items: Kitchenware, dishes, and decor at low prices.
Location Details:
- Address: 510 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH 45840
- Phone: (419) 423-9151
- Hours: Open 24 hours
Frequently Asked Questions
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Findlay is a great way to save money, support local businesses, and find all kinds of useful items. From clothes and furniture to tools and gifts, each store has something different to offer. I hope this guide helps you decide where to go based on what you’re looking for.
Whether you’re a regular thrifter or just starting out, there’s always a deal waiting around the corner. Happy thrifting, and don’t forget to check back for more local tips!
