If you are looking for good deals and fun shopping, Evansville has many great thrift stores to check out. You can find clothes, shoes, furniture, books, and more at very low prices. Many of these shops also support local causes, which makes shopping feel even better. I visited several places and found some amazing items for myself and my family. These are some of the best thrift stores in Evansville where you can find nice things without spending too much.
Each store has its own style and types of items. Some shops focus on kids’ clothes, while others have fancy dresses or furniture. Most of them are clean, well-organized, and have friendly workers. You never know what you might find, and that’s what makes it fun. Thrift shopping in Evansville is a great way to save money and find treasures.
Best Thrift Shops in Evansville – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Thrift Store by Evansville Rescue Mission | Clothes, housewares, cheap furniture | Shopping near closing time | Very affordable | Clean, organized, friendly | Early in the day |
| Camilla’s Closet | Stylish, name-brand clothes & accessories | Tight budgets | Mid-range (higher than regular thrift) | Boutique-like, upscale | Weekdays for fewer crowds |
| World Wide Missions Consignment Store | Big selections, unique finds | Quick or new items | Super cheap | Crowded, treasure-hunt feel | Weekends for fresh stock |
| St. Vincent de Paul Society Thrift Store | Kids’ books, household basics | High-end shoppers | Low prices | Cozy, quiet, friendly | Midweek for relaxed shopping |
| AbyssCo | vintage items, fun finds | Everyday basics | Fair prices | Eclectic, artsy | Weekends for longer hours |
| Philthy Vintage Clothing | Vintage tees, pop culture gear | Business/dressy clothes | $5-$25 bins | Chill, retro | Afternoons for best selection |
| American Pride Thrift Store and More | Antiques, tools, vintage decor | Trendy fashion | Budget-friendly | Rustic, local feel | Weekdays for deals |
| Style Encore Evansville | Women’s fashion & accessories | Men’s clothes | Mid-range | Polished, organized | Weekends for sales |
| Habitat for Humanity ReStore | Furniture, home improvement items | Clothes/small items | Fair prices | Warehouse-like, helpful | Weekdays for best stock |
| Kids Consignment LLC | Kids’ clothes, baby gear | Adult items | Very affordable | Bright, family-friendly | Mornings for new arrivals |
| Molly’s Upscale Consignment Boutique | Designer women’s fashion | Budget shoppers | Higher-end | Chic, boutique-like | Weekdays for personal help |
| Strouse’s | Women’s classic clothing & jewelry | Kids/electronics | Reasonable | Cozy, timeless | Weekdays for quiet browsing |
| AnnaLe’s Twice Chosen Bridal & Prom | Wedding/prom dresses | Casual clothes | Varies (great deals) | Glamorous, welcoming | Weekends for appointments |
The Thrift Store by Evansville Rescue Mission
The Thrift Store by Evansville Rescue Mission is a really nice place to shop if you like saving money and finding all kinds of things. The store is clean, smells fresh, and is well organized, so it’s easy to look around. They have clothes for babies, kids, and adults, plus house stuff like dishes, decorations, and even furniture and mattresses. I also saw some working appliances, which is a nice surprise at a thrift store. Most of the prices are low compared to other stores, and it feels good knowing the money helps people in need.
The store is part of a local mission that’s been helping people in Evansville for over 100 years. Some of the workers are friendly, but a few can be strict, especially near closing time. So it’s better to shop earlier in the day. Even with that, this place is one of the best thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana for finding all kinds of stuff in one stop. It’s great if you like hunting for deals and supporting a good cause.
- Best for: Clothes, housewares, and cheap furniture
- Not ideal for: Shopping close to closing time
- My top picks: Brand new mattresses, kitchen items, men’s clothes
- Location details:
📍 1107 Washington Square, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 421-3803
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–6 PM, Sunday: Closed
Camilla’s Closet
Camilla’s Closet is a great place if you like nice clothes but don’t want to pay full price. The store is inside Eastland Mall, and it looks more like a fancy boutique than a thrift shop. Everything is very clean, easy to look through, and well sorted by type and brand. You can find a lot of name-brand clothes here, like jackets, shoes, bags, and jewelry. I’ve found really cute things here that still had the tags on them, which means they were never worn.
The prices are higher than regular thrift stores, but you’re paying for better stuff. Sometimes they have sales, and that helps a lot. I like coming here just to look around even if I don’t buy something every time. It’s one of the nicest consignment shops in Evansville, Indiana if you’re into fashion or want to find something a little fancier.
- Best for: Stylish, name-brand clothes and accessories
- Not ideal for: Shopping on a very tight budget
- My top picks: Handbags, statement necklaces, trendy shoes
- Location details:
📍 1330 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 401-1191
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM, Sunday: 12 PM–6 PM
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Bloomington
St. Vincent de Paul Society Thrift Store
St. Vincent de Paul Society Thrift Store is smaller than other places, but it has a cozy and friendly feeling. The people who work there are super nice and make you feel welcome. I’ve found some great deals here, especially on kids’ books and small household stuff. The prices are fair, and it’s not crowded, so you can shop in peace without feeling rushed or overwhelmed. It’s a quiet place where you can take your time and look around.
Even though it’s not very big, they still have a lot to offer. There’s free parking, and it’s easy to get in and out. If you like a calm shopping trip and helpful staff, this is a wonderful spot. This store is one of the top rated thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana because of its friendly vibe and simple, helpful setup.
- Best for: Kids’ books and basic household items
- Not ideal for: High-end or brand-name shoppers
- My top picks: Children’s books, dishes, pillowcases
- Location details:
📍 767 E Walnut St, Evansville, IN 47713
📞 (812) 425-3148
🕒 Tuesday–Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM, Sunday–Monday: Closed
World Wide Missions Consignment Store
World Wide Missions Consignment Store is one of the biggest thrift stores I’ve been to in Evansville. You can spend hours here because there’s so much to see. They have clothes, furniture, glassware, toys, decorations, and all kinds of random things. It feels like they accept just about everything, which means there’s always something new each time you go. The prices are low, and the workers are kind and helpful if you need anything.
Some things may be worn or old, so it’s good to look closely before buying, especially electronics or baby items. But if you like digging through lots of stuff to find a few treasures, this is a great place to do it. I think this is one of the best thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana for people who like to look around and find unique things.
- Best for: Digging through big selections to find good deals
- Not ideal for: Shoppers who want quick or new items
- My top picks: Coffee mugs, used furniture, vintage décor
- Location details:
📍 301 N Congress Ave, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 471-3466
🕒 Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–4:50 PM, Sunday: Closed
AbyssCo
AbyssCo is a really fun and quirky place to shop. Every time I stop by, I find something totally different and unique. They have used clothes, vintage jewelry, cassette tapes, old books, and even small home items. It’s located behind Exotica on Washington Ave, so it feels kind of like a hidden treasure. The shop is small but full of cool stuff that you won’t find at big stores.
The people working there are super friendly and make you feel welcome. I think AbyssCo is one of the best thrift shops in Evansville if you like digging through unique and fun items. The prices are fair, and it’s fun to look around, even if you don’t buy something every time. I like going on weekends when they’re open a little later, and I always walk out with something unexpected and fun.
- Best for: Quirky, one-of-a-kind vintage finds
- Not ideal for: Everyday basics or large furniture
- My top picks: Vintage toys, cassette tapes, jewelry
- Location details:
📍 4597 Washington Ave, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 491-6661
🕒 Mon & Sun: 12–6 PM; Thurs: 12–6 PM; Fri & Sat: 12–8 PM; Tues & Wed: Closed
Philthy Vintage Clothing
If you’re into cool old T-shirts, band shirts, or pop culture clothes, Philthy Vintage is the place to go. It’s small but packed with racks of vintage sportswear, music gear, and movie tees. The $5 and $10 bins are amazing, you can find some real gems in there without spending a lot. The vibe is super chill, and the owner is always up for a chat.
This spot really stands out among the vintage thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana. It’s got that old-school charm with clothes that tell a story. The staff is fun and the music playing in the background adds to the experience. I like stopping by when I’m on the west side and always leave with something cool to add to my collection.
- Best for: Pop culture and vintage T-shirts
- Not ideal for: Business or dressy clothing
- My top picks: $5 bin tees, retro sports gear, jackets
- Location details:
📍 2017 W Franklin St, Evansville, IN 47712
📞 (812) 550-1469
🕒 Tues–Sat: 12–6 PM; Sun: 12–5 PM; Mon: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Indianapolis
American Pride Thrift Store and More
American Pride is a locally owned and veteran-run shop that has a little bit of everything. The shelves are packed with all kinds of treasures, old tools, vintage home decor, antiques, clothes, and even barber gear. It’s one of those shops where you never know what you’ll find, and that’s part of the fun. The prices are really reasonable, especially compared to bigger chains.
This is a great choice when you’re looking for second hand stores in Evansville, Indiana that feel truly local. The owner is usually around and very helpful. I like coming here when I’m in the mood to dig through things and look for something different. It’s not a fancy place, but it’s honest and budget-friendly, which makes it worth coming back to.
- Best for: Antiques, tools, and vintage decor
- Not ideal for: Trendy fashion or upscale goods
- My top picks: Barber gear, vintage tools, collectible antiques
- Location details:
📍 2346 Washington Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
📞 (812) 777-0105
🕒 Mon–Fri: 10 AM–4 PM; Sat: 10 AM–3 PM; Sun: Closed
Style Encore Evansville
Style Encore is a clean, well-organized consignment shop focused on women’s fashion. They have everything from casual clothes to business wear, shoes, bags, and jewelry. The store always looks neat, and it’s easy to find something in your size because they carry sizes from 0 to 6X. They also buy gently used items, so it’s a great way to earn a little cash, too.
For those shopping for fashion deals, this is one of the top consignment shops in Evansville, Indiana. I’ve picked up name brand clothes for a fraction of what they cost in the mall. It’s nice to shop in a place that’s both affordable and stylish. If you’re looking for polished outfits without spending too much, this is the place to go.
- Best for: Women’s fashion and accessories
- Not ideal for: Men’s clothes or vintage items
- My top picks: Name brand tops, handbags, plus-size clothing
- Location details:
📍 833 N Green River Rd, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 471-7180
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–8 PM; Sun: 11 AM–6 PM
Habitat for Humanity ReStore
ReStore is a large thrift store that mainly sells home improvement items, furniture, appliances, and tools. It’s also a great place to find gently used home goods at good prices. The best part is that your purchases support Habitat for Humanity, so you’re helping others while you shop. The staff is always friendly and happy to help load big items.
If you’re looking for furniture thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana, this one should be on your list. I’ve bought shelves, lamps, and even a sink here, and all were in good shape. It’s also a good stop if you like doing DIY projects or just want to search for unique items for your house. Just be ready to haul things home since some items are large.
- Best for: Furniture and home improvement items
- Not ideal for: Clothes or small collectibles
- My top picks: Lamps, shelving, cabinets
- Location details:
📍 1301 N Royal Ave, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 602-3460
🕒 Mon–Fri: 9 AM–5 PM; Sat: 9 AM–4 PM; Sun: Closed
Kids Consignment LLC
Kids Consignment LLC is a very nice store for finding clothes, shoes, and toys for babies and children. Everything in the store is gently used but still looks clean and good. I like how everything is sorted by size and type, so it is easy to find what you are looking for. You can find brand-name items here at prices that are much cheaper than new. They also have a nice selection of books and baby gear like strollers and high chairs.
The people who work here are very friendly and helpful. They always greet you when you walk in and ask if you need help. The store is bright, clean, and not too crowded, which makes shopping more comfortable. If you are a parent or grandparent, this is one of the best consignment shops in Evansville, Indiana for finding good-quality children’s items at low prices. I come back often because the prices and quality are both great.
- Best for: Kids’ clothing and baby gear
- Not ideal for: Adult clothing or home décor
- My top picks: Toddler shoes, baby books, strollers
- Location details:
📍 4201 Hogue Rd, Evansville, IN 47712
📞 (812) 401-5437
🕒 Monday–Friday: 10 AM–4 PM; Saturday: 10 AM–2 PM; Sunday: Closed
Molly’s Upscale Consignment Boutique
Molly’s is one of the most stylish thrift stores I have visited in Evansville. It feels more like a boutique than a secondhand store because the items are so fancy and clean. They sell name-brand and designer clothes, shoes, perfume, and jewelry. If you like fashion and want to find high-end items for lower prices, this is the right place to shop. Everything is well organized and easy to look through.
The workers are very friendly and make you feel welcome every time you visit. They are helpful if you need help finding something or have questions about brands. Molly’s is a great choice if you love dressing up but don’t want to spend too much. It’s definitely one of the top 10 best thrift stores in Evansville, Indiana for stylish women’s fashion. I always find something special when I stop by.
- Best for: Upscale women’s fashion
- Not ideal for: Men’s clothing or furniture
- My top picks: Designer shoes, handbags, perfumes
- Location details:
📍 5600 E Virginia St, Evansville, IN 47715
📞 (812) 479-7505
🕒 Monday: 10 AM–3:30 PM; Tuesday: 10 AM–4:30 PM; Wednesday–Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM; Sunday: Closed
Strouse’s
Strouse’s is a small but very nice consignment shop that has been part of Evansville for many years. The store mainly sells women’s clothing, jewelry, cookbooks, and home goods. What I like most is the good quality of the items and the mix of classic and newer styles. You can find well-known brands here, and the prices are fair. It’s a cozy store with a peaceful feeling that makes it easy to enjoy your shopping.
The staff is very polite and helpful, and the store is always neat and clean. It’s not a very big store, but the items are carefully chosen, and there’s always something new to see. If you enjoy looking for special pieces, Strouse’s is one of the best resale stores Evansville, Indiana has for women’s fashion and accessories. I often come here when I want to find something unique and classy.
- Best for: Women’s clothing and accessories
- Not ideal for: Kids’ items or electronics
- My top picks: Purses, necklaces, seasonal clothing
- Location details:
📍 4601 Lincoln Ave, Evansville, IN 47714
📞 (812) 471-7153
🕒 Tuesday–Saturday: 11 AM–4 PM; Sunday–Monday: Closed
AnnaLe’s Twice Chosen Bridal & Prom Consignment Shop
AnnaLe’s is a wonderful store for anyone looking for a wedding dress, prom dress, or pageant gown. The store has a large collection of beautiful dresses in many styles and sizes. Some are brand new, and some are gently used, but all are very pretty and in great condition. They also sell shoes, jewelry, and other accessories to go with the dresses. This shop makes it easy to find something perfect for your big day without spending too much.
The ladies who work there are very kind and helpful. They take their time to help you find the right dress and make sure you feel comfortable while shopping. It’s a happy place with a lot of sparkle and charm. If you’re planning a special event, this is one of the best second hand stores in Evansville, Indiana for formal wear. I had a great time looking around and will definitely return.
- Best for: Bridal, prom, and formal wear
- Not ideal for: Everyday clothes or casual shoes
- My top picks: Wedding gowns, high heels, earrings
- Location details:
📍 4521 Lincoln Ave Suite 102, Evansville, IN 47714
📞 (812) 473-0239
🕒 Tuesday: 3–6 PM; Wednesday–Thursday: 12–6 PM; Friday: 12–4 PM; Saturday: 10 AM–4 PM; Sunday: 1–4 PM; Monday: Closed
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Evansville can be a fun and smart way to find what you need. Whether you are looking for clothes, shoes, furniture, or something special, these stores have a little bit of everything. The prices are low, the people are friendly, and you can find good quality items without spending too much. Each store is different, so it’s worth visiting more than one. I hope this list helps you enjoy shopping at some of the best thrift stores in Evansville.
