Thrift shopping is a fun and easy way to save money and find great things. Whether you’re looking for clothes, furniture, or home items, Madison has lots of good places to check out. In this guide, I’ll share some of the best thrift stores in Madison. These shops have all kinds of secondhand items, and many also support local causes. You never know what treasure you might find!
I’ve visited these stores myself and had good experiences at each one. Some are great for clothes, others for furniture or gifts. The prices are usually low, and the staff are often kind and helpful. I like shopping at these places because it feels good to reuse things and support the community. Let’s take a look at some of my favorites around town.
Best Thrift Shops in Madison – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dig & Save Outlet | Super cheap clothes by the pound | Neat/organized shoppers | Extremely low | Lively, treasure hunt | Weekday mornings |
| Willy Street Treasure Shop | Gifts, small home items | Clothing or furniture | Budget-friendly | Cozy, quiet | Weekends (limited hours) |
| Upshift Swap and Thrift | Eco-friendly clothing swaps | Non-clothing items | Swap-based ($20) | Stylish, boutique-like | Weekends (full selection) |
| Agrace Thrift Store | Furniture, home goods | Trendy fashion | Affordable | Calm, organized | Weekday afternoons |
| ReThreads | Trendy/vintage clothing | Furniture/home goods | Moderate | Hip, boutique-style | Weekends (busy but fun) |
| Boomerangs Resale | Family clothes, home décor | High-end fashion | Cheap | Friendly, community vibe | Weekdays (less crowded) |
| Happy Hours | Unique gifts, colorful clothes | Bulk or large items | Fair | Quirky, creative | Fridays/Saturdays (events) |
| Rewind Decor | Vintage home decor | Clothing shoppers | Moderate | Retro, artsy | Weekends (only open Sat-Sun) |
| Habitat ReStore – West | Furniture, DIY supplies | Clothing/accessories | Very cheap | Spacious, practical | Weekdays (restocked often) |
| Stillgood’s | Stylish consignment fashion | Home goods | Moderate | Chic, curated | Weekends (trendy finds) |
| Goodwill Madison North | Basics, household items | Trying on clothes (no rooms) | Budget-friendly | Spacious, no-frills | Evenings (open late) |
| Dane County Humane Society | Pet supplies, supporting animals | Large furniture | Cheap | Warm, charitable | Weekdays (support cause) |
| BHA Services Thrift Store | Estate finds, random treasures | Organized shoppers | Very cheap | Eclectic, dig-friendly | Weekends (new stock) |
Dig & Save Outlet
If you like hunting for bargains, this place is a dream. At Dig & Save Outlet, you go through big bins filled with clothes, bags, shoes, and more. Most items are sold by the pound, which means you can find a full outfit for just a few dollars. I once paid less than $2 for pants, a shirt, and a scarf! The store is big and open, and people are always friendly and helpful.
This is one of the best second hand stores in Madison, Wisconsin if you’re okay with doing a little digging. The stock changes every day, so it’s fun to check often. You’ll see college students, families, and vintage lovers all shopping here. Just remember, it’s not fancy, and things aren’t organized by size, so take your time and enjoy the search.
- Best for: Super cheap clothing and digging for hidden gems
- Not ideal for: Shoppers who want things organized neatly
- My top picks: Clothes by the pound, bags, and bedsheets
- Location details:
📍 1900 S Park St, Madison, WI 53713
📞 (608) 278-2920 ext. 499
🕒 Open every day, 10 AM–5 PM
Willy Street Treasure Shop
Willy Street Treasure Shop is a small and quiet place that feels very welcoming. When I first visited, I didn’t expect to find much, but I was surprised. There were cute gifts, small home items, and even some things that looked brand new. The prices are fair, and everything is easy to see on the shelves. It’s clean and calm, and not crowded like bigger stores.
This is one of the nicest little thrift shops Madison, Wisconsin has if you want a slow, peaceful shopping trip. It’s a great spot if you enjoy looking for hidden treasures without the stress. Some people might think it’s too small, but I think that’s what makes it special. I always find something fun or useful when I stop by. Just don’t forget to check their hours, they’re only open on certain days.
- Best for: Gift shopping and cute home items
- Not ideal for: Clothing or large furniture pieces
- My top picks: Candles, mugs, frames
- Location details:
📍 1236 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703
🕒 Open Thurs–Sun, 11 AM–4 PM
Upshift Swap and Thrift
Upshift Swap and Thrift is a really fun and unique place to shop. You bring your gently used clothes and pay $20, then you can pick out new clothes to take home. It feels like trading, and it’s a great way to refresh your closet without wasting money. The store looks more like a fancy boutique than a regular thrift shop. It’s clean, colorful, and the staff are always friendly and helpful.
This is one of the most stylish and eco-friendly clothing thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin. I found cool jackets and comfy shoes here that I still wear all the time. It’s a great spot if you love fashion but also care about the planet. Just remember, they only take clothes, no furniture or kitchen stuff. I always leave with something new and feel good about the swap.
- Best for: Fashion lovers and eco-friendly shoppers
- Not ideal for: Furniture or home goods shopping
- My top picks: Jackets, handbags, stylish tops
- Location details:
📍 836 E Johnson St, Madison, WI 53703
📞 No phone number listed
🕒 Mon–Fri 12–4 PM; Sat–Sun 10 AM–4 PM
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Milwaukee
Agrace Thrift Store
Agrace Thrift Store is a calm and clean place to shop. Everything is neatly set up, and it’s easy to look through the clothes, furniture, and small home items. I once found a cute lamp and a soft armchair here, both in great shape and for a low price. The workers are friendly and always ready to help if you need anything. They even offer to pick up donations, which is really helpful when you’re cleaning out your home.
This is one of the best furniture thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin if you want nice things for your house at good prices. Plus, when you shop here, your money goes to helping people who are sick or getting older. That makes finding a good deal feel even better. It’s not the place to go if you’re looking for trendy clothes, but for home items, it’s one of my favorites. I always leave with something useful and feel good about my purchase.
- Best for: Furniture, clean home goods, and supporting a good cause
- Not ideal for: Trendy or rare fashion items
- My top picks: Tables, lamps, nice secondhand clothes
- Location details:
📍 118 Junction Rd, Madison, WI 53717
📞 (608) 327-7072
🕒 Mon–Sat 10 AM–5 PM; Closed Sundays
ReThreads
ReThreads is a fun and stylish thrift store right in the middle of State Street. It’s a great spot to buy cool clothes or even sell the ones you don’t wear anymore. I’ve found great pieces here like leather jackets, designer jeans, and nice boots. Everything is clean and sorted by size, which makes it easy to shop. The workers are kind and help you find items that fit your look.
This is one of the best clothing thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin if you love fashion and want good quality without spending a lot. The store feels more like a small boutique than a typical thrift store. They have both modern and vintage styles, and the prices are fair for the brands you get. I like to stop by when I want to add something fun or different to my closet. It’s perfect for people who want style on a budget.
- Best for: Trendy clothes, vintage styles, buy-sell-trade
- Not ideal for: Furniture or home item shoppers
- My top picks: Coats, jeans, vintage tops
- Location details:
📍 410 State St, Madison, WI 53703
📞 (608) 257-1018
🕒 Mon–Fri 12–6 PM; Sat 11 AM–6 PM; Sun 12–5 PM
Boomerangs Resale Store
Boomerangs Resale Store is a clean and friendly thrift store on Madison’s north side. When I visited, I was happy to see how neat and organized everything was. They have clothes for all ages, some nice furniture, and even home decorations. The people working there are very nice and always ready to help. It’s a calm place to shop and easy to find what you need.
This is one of the best resale stores Madison, Wisconsin has, especially if you want good quality and fair prices. All the money made here goes to support local community programs, which makes shopping feel even better. I always find something useful, whether it’s a warm sweater or a kitchen item. It’s not a huge store, but it has a lot of heart.
- Best for: Family clothing, home goods, kind service
- Not ideal for: Trendy or high-fashion items
- My top picks: Sweaters, home décor, kids’ clothes
- Location details:
📍 1133 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704
📞 (608) 268-0793
🕒 Tues–Fri 10 AM–6 PM; Sat 10 AM–4 PM; Closed Sun–Mon
Happy Hours
Happy Hours is a small shop, but it’s packed with charm. The store has a mix of fun secondhand clothes, gifts, and cute home items. The owner, Ali, picks each item herself, and you can tell she puts a lot of heart into it. I’ve found colorful sweaters, handmade candles, and even little decorations that made great gifts. It feels more like a cozy boutique than your usual thrift store.
This is one of the most fun and creative thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin to visit. They sometimes host cool events, and the shop also helps support the local community. The prices are fair, and you can always find something unique. It’s a small space, so it can get a bit busy, but it’s totally worth the visit. Just be sure to check their hours before you go, since they’re not open every day.
- Best for: Cute clothes, gifts, and home items
- Not ideal for: Big furniture or bulk shopping
- My top picks: Colorful tops, candles, small décor
- Location details:
📍 223 E Mifflin St, Madison, WI 53703
🕒 Mon & Thurs 12–4 PM; Fri 10 AM–6 PM; Sat 9 AM–5 PM; Closed Sun–Wed
Related: Best Thrift Stores in Appleton
Rewind Decor
Rewind Decor is a fun little shop full of vintage treasures. They have cool mid-century furniture, funky lamps, and creative home decorations. Every time I stop by, I find something different, like a cute planter or a unique wall piece. The store is small but packed with fun stuff to look through. The owner is always friendly and happy to talk about the items.
If you like decorating with retro style, this is one of the best vintage thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin. They don’t sell clothes, but their furniture and home décor are amazing. It’s a great place to find something special that you won’t see anywhere else. Just remember, they’re only open on weekends, so plan your visit ahead of time. It’s one of my favorite places to shop for home pieces that stand out.
- Best for: Vintage home items, unique decorations
- Not ideal for: Clothing or big furniture pieces
- My top picks: Retro chairs, handmade planters, wall art
- Location details:
📍 1336 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703
📞 (608) 509-7995
🕒 Sat–Sun 11 AM–5 PM; Closed Mon–Fri
Habitat ReStore
Habitat ReStore – West is one of my favorite spots when I need something for my home. The store is big and full of used furniture, home tools, light fixtures, and appliances. I like to stop by when I’m working on a DIY project or when I want to fix up a room without spending too much. Everything is organized nicely, and the workers are always kind and ready to help. You never know what you’ll find, which makes each visit exciting.
This is definitely one of the best furniture thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin. The prices are low, and what you spend helps local families through Habitat for Humanity. They don’t carry clothes, but if you’re looking for furniture or home items, this place is perfect. I’ve found chairs, shelves, and even light bulbs here for super cheap. It’s a great store to explore if you like home projects or just want to save money.
- Best for: Furniture, tools, home improvement items
- Not ideal for: Clothing or fashion accessories
- My top picks: Shelves, chairs, light fixtures
- Location details:
📍 6201 Odana Rd, Madison, WI 53719
📞 (608) 442-9919
🕒 Tues–Sat 9 AM–5 PM; Closed Sun–Mon
Stillgood’s
Stillgood’s is a small but very stylish secondhand store. They have a mix of modern and vintage clothes, and every item feels special. I like how clean and nicely decorated the store is, it feels welcoming as soon as you walk in. The staff is super helpful and always ready to give you tips or help you find the right size. I often find cool jeans, dresses, or fun accessories here.
This is one of the best consignment shops in Madison, Wisconsin if you’re looking for fashion that’s unique and well-priced. You can even bring in your old clothes and trade them for store credit, which I love. They don’t carry furniture, but their clothes and jewelry are always worth checking out. Everything feels carefully chosen, and I always leave happy. It’s a fun place to refresh your style without spending too much.
- Best for: Stylish clothes, vintage fashion, buy-sell-trade
- Not ideal for: Home goods or furniture
- My top picks: Vintage jeans, cute tops, earrings
- Location details:
📍 1521 Williamson St, Madison, WI 53703
📞 (608) 405-5899
🕒 Wed–Sun 11 AM–5 PM; Closed Mon–Tues
Goodwill
Goodwill Madison North is a popular place to find gently used items at low prices. They have a big mix of things, clothes for men, women, and kids, plus shoes, books, and housewares. I always find something useful here, whether it’s a jacket or a DVD. The store is clean and well-organized, and there’s lots of space to walk around. The only downside is they don’t have fitting rooms.
If you’re on the hunt for everyday basics, this is one of the most reliable thrift shops Madison, Wisconsin has to offer. You can visit anytime during the week since they stay open late. It’s perfect for families, students, or anyone who loves a good deal. There’s always something new to look through, so it’s worth checking in often.
- Best for: Basic clothing, shoes, and household items
- Not ideal for: Trying on clothes (no fitting rooms)
- My top picks: Jeans, men’s jackets, DVDs
- Location details:
📍 2901 N Sherman Ave, Madison, WI 53704
📞 (608) 819-8082
🕒 Mon–Sat 9 AM–8 PM; Sun 10 AM–6 PM
Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store
Dane County Humane Society Thrift Store is a small shop with a kind heart. They sell secondhand clothes, home items, books, and even pet supplies. The best part is that all the money goes to help animals at the shelter. The store is neat and cozy, and the people who work there are always smiling and ready to help. I always enjoy shopping here because it feels good to support a good cause.
This is one of the most caring and top rated thrift stores in Madison, Wisconsin, especially if you love animals. The prices are great, and there’s always something fun to find, from clothes to cute home goods. It’s also the perfect place to grab toys or supplies for your pets. I stop by often and usually leave with something useful or special. Shopping here makes a difference for both people and animals.
- Best for: Supporting animal rescue, home items, pet supplies
- Not ideal for: Large furniture or high-end fashion
- My top picks: Pet bowls, candles, sweaters
- Location details:
📍 6904 Watts Rd, Madison, WI 53719
📞 (608) 709-1275
🕒 Mon & Sun 11 AM–5 PM; Tues–Sat 11 AM–7 PM
BHA Services Thrift Store
BHA Services is a cool spot if you enjoy looking through lots of different things. It’s not your typical thrift store, they don’t take donations but buy full estates, so there’s always new and random stuff to see. You’ll find furniture, tools, books, and all kinds of household goods. It’s a little messy and not super organized, but that’s part of the fun. I once found an old record player and a really nice lamp for cheap.
This is one of the most unique second hand stores in Madison, Wisconsin. It’s a great place if you like taking your time and hunting for treasures. I always discover something unexpected whenever I go. The prices are low, and the selection is huge. Just know it’s not fancy, so come ready to dig around a little.
- Best for: Unique finds, estate goods, tools and books
- Not ideal for: Organized shopping or quick visits
- My top picks: Used tools, old books, chairs
- Location details:
📍 3365 E Washington Ave, Madison, WI 53704
📞 (608) 298-7707
🕒 Tues 10 AM–7 PM; Wed–Fri 10 AM–6 PM; Sat 10 AM–6 PM; Sun 12–5 PM; Closed Mon
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Madison is a great way to save money, find unique things, and support local stores. Each shop has something special to offer, whether it’s clothes, furniture, or fun home items. You can enjoy the hunt while doing something good for the community. I hope this list helps you find your new favorite thrift store. Happy thrifting!
