If you’re looking for the best thrift stores in Youngstown, you’re about to have a great time shopping. Whether you’re after secondhand clothes, used furniture, or vintage decorations, Youngstown has a wide variety of shops worth checking out. From small boutiques to large resale centers, there’s something here for every kind of thrifter, especially if you love saving money and finding unique items.
As someone who enjoys going thrifting around town, I’ve visited all kinds of local shops and resale stores. In this guide, I’m sharing my personal favorites along with details like what each store is best for, what they don’t usually carry, and my top picks. I also included store hours and locations to make your next shopping trip easier.
Best Thrift Shops in Youngstown – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schulte’s Thrift Yard | Furniture, quirky home items | Clothing, neatly organized sections | Very affordable | Laid-back, treasure hunt | Weekday mornings |
| Good Vibes | Unique décor, vintage oddities | Apparel, everyday basics | Moderate | Artsy, friendly | Thursday–Saturday afternoons |
| Penny Pinchers | Women’s clothes, accessories | Men’s items, vintage finds | Budget-friendly | Clean, simple | Weekdays |
| Raks Nearly New | Quality consignment, home décor | Deep discounts, bulk deals | Fair prices | Bright, organized | Weekday afternoons |
| Thrift & Thrive at the Farm | Kids’ items, handmade goods | Large clothing selection | Super cheap | Cozy, community feel | Thursday–Saturday mornings |
| Youngstown Area Goodwill | Housewares, clothing, décor | Highly curated items | Great deals | Busy but efficient | Weekday mornings |
| Angels Mission | Affordable clothes, toys | Furniture, high-end brands | Very low prices | Small but packed | Weekday afternoons |
| St. Vincent de Paul | Budget basics, kitchen items | Trendy or stylish pieces | Extremely cheap | Community-focused | Tuesday–Friday mornings |
| Consign & Design | Upscale consignment, home décor | Bargain-bin shopping | Mid-range | Boutique-like, calm | Weekday afternoons |
| Vintage of 330 | Bold vintage fashion | Everyday wear, kids’ clothes | Moderate to high | Funky, personalized | Weekday afternoons |
| The Overstock Shoppe | Discount home goods | Clothing, books | Low prices | Quiet, practical | Weekday mornings |
| Star Supply | Odd hardware/home finds | Furniture, clothing | Bargain deals | Cluttered but fun | Weekday mornings |
| Ms. Charolette’s | Boutique-style resale fashion | Furniture, large inventory | Fair prices | Charming, personal | Weekday afternoons |
| Retro Ohio | Vintage furniture, records | Clothing, cheap deals | Pricier but worth it | Nostalgic, curated | Friday–Saturday afternoons |
| Economy Furniture | Affordable new/used furniture | Small thrift items | Budget-friendly | Practical, helpful staff | Weekday mornings |
Schulte’s Thrift Yard
Schulte’s Thrift Yard is the kind of place where you never know what cool item you’ll find. The shop has a variety of used furniture, housewares, and quirky items at prices that won’t break the bank. The owner and staff are friendly and relaxed, which makes shopping here a comfortable experience.
One thing I like is that everything is clearly priced, and most of the items are in good condition. The store isn’t huge, but it has a lot of value packed into it. Whether you’re looking for a new piece of furniture or just something small for your home, there are always options to choose from.
I’ve picked up vintage tools, unique home decor, and even some random items I didn’t know I needed. This place is great for people who enjoy searching through all kinds of things and don’t mind a little dust. The inventory changes often, so it’s always a good idea to visit regularly.
It’s not about everything being perfectly arranged, but more about the fun of finding something interesting. I always leave with something useful or fun, and I bet you will too!
- Best for: Low-cost household items, furniture, and unexpected finds
- Not ideal for: Clothing or well-organized sections
- My Top Picks: Used tool kits, retro kitchenware, side tables
- Location: Located in: West Side Youngstown
Address: 1648 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44509
Contact No: (330) 261-8428
Operating Hours:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday–Saturday: 9 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Shops In Canton
Good Vibes
Good Vibes really lives up to its name. The store may be small, but it’s packed with character and charm. Inside, you’ll find a unique mix of vintage home goods, quirky décor, and secondhand items that are truly one of a kind. The owners are incredibly friendly and make you feel right at home as soon as you walk in.
They put a lot of thought into what they sell, so you won’t see the same stuff you’d find in a big chain store. It’s the type of place where you can stumble upon a funky lamp, a vintage mirror, or a piece of décor you never knew you needed. Everything is carefully chosen, which makes it feel like you’re getting a glimpse into their personal collection.
The best part about Good Vibes is the fun mix of items they carry. One shelf might hold an old retro lamp, and the next could have a glittery disco ball or a colorful vase. It’s not like the usual thrift stores you might find, which is exactly what makes it special. There’s always something different to look at, so every visit is a little adventure.
They change their inventory often, so you’ll never know what you might find. But keep in mind, they’re only open three days a week, so you’ll need to plan your visit. If you love quirky and artsy pieces that stand out, this is the place to go. Every time I visit, I leave with something unexpected, and that’s what makes it such a great stop on my thrifting journey.
- Best for: Unique décor, vintage oddities, friendly service
- Not ideal for: Apparel or everyday household basics
- My Top Picks: Glassware sets, funky lamps, decorative items
- Location: Located in: Mahoning Avenue strip
Address: 2714 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44509
Contact No: (330) 333-3232
Operating Hours:
Monday–Wednesday: Closed
Thursday–Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Penny Pinchers
Penny Pinchers is a great mix of thrift and consignment, offering a range of gently used clothes and home goods. The store is always clean and well-organized, making it easy to find what you need. The staff are friendly and welcoming, always ready to help but never pushy, which makes the shopping experience relaxed.
The prices are fair, and if you’re lucky, you can catch some great seasonal markdowns. You’ll find a solid selection of women’s clothing, shoes, and accessories, and the store layout is simple, so it’s easy to browse without feeling overwhelmed by too many items.
I personally love Penny Pinchers for those times when I need something practical and affordable. It’s not flashy or fancy, but it’s always reliable and tidy. If you’re on a tight budget and want a stress-free shopping experience, this is the perfect place to check out.
They also occasionally have some furniture pieces, so it’s a good spot if you’re looking to add a little something to your home without breaking the bank. I find myself coming back here regularly for simple, well-priced finds.
- Best for: Women’s clothing, accessories, and small home accents
- Not ideal for: Men’s items or vintage-specific finds
- My Top Picks: Crossbody bags, cardigans, gently used boots
- Location: Located in: Market Street Plaza
Address: 6826 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512
Contact No: (330) 788-6736
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores In Lorain
Raks Nearly New
Raks Nearly New is a long-time favorite for people who love consignment shopping. The store is always clean and bright, with a nice selection of clothes, home décor, and small furniture pieces. The aisles are wide, so it’s easy to move around and look at everything.
They really keep things organized, and I’ve found a lot of great items here, like name-brand jeans and unique framed art. The prices are fair for what you get, especially since they carry well-known brands. If you’re looking for something special, this is a good place to check out.
I like to go to Raks Nearly New when I want to buy something that’s good quality and will last. While the store isn’t the cheapest, you’re getting solid items that will hold up over time. The store is always neat, and it’s easy to find things because everything is well-organized.
The staff are kind and ready to help if you need it. If you want a simple and straightforward shopping experience with good quality items, this store is a great choice.
- Best for: Clean, quality consignment clothes and home décor
- Not ideal for: Deep discounts or bulk deals
- My Top Picks: Denim, framed artwork, glass home décor
- Location: Located in: Belmont Avenue strip
Address: 3800 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH 44505
Contact No: (330) 759-1753
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Saturday: 10 AM – 4 PM
Sunday: Closed
Thrift & Thrive at the Farm
Thrift & Thrive at the Farm is a smaller store that has a calm and welcoming atmosphere. It’s a mix of thrift shop and community center, and everything is neatly organized. I’ve found items like baby clothes, handmade crafts, and various home goods, all in great condition. The store is run by volunteers who make sure it stays clean and pleasant.
The prices are very affordable, which makes it easy to grab a few extra items without breaking the bank. The selection changes regularly, so you’ll always find something new if you visit often. I’ve also spotted some unique, handmade pieces that you wouldn’t find anywhere else.
Even though it’s only open three days a week, it’s worth checking out if you can make it. The store has a relaxing vibe, and shopping here feels like you’re supporting a good cause while picking up some great finds. It’s a quieter spot, perfect for shoppers who enjoy a more peaceful experience without the hustle of busy crowds.
If you like shopping with a purpose, this is a great place to visit. The staff is friendly and happy to chat if you need help. Plus, the store regularly hosts community events, making it a great place to connect with others while finding deals.
- Best for: Kids’ items, handmade goods, quiet shopping
- Not ideal for: Clothing variety or large stock
- My Top Picks: Baby onesies, handmade gifts, small home goods
- Location: Located in: Western Reserve Farm area
Address: 3279 E Western Reserve Rd, Youngstown, OH 44514
Contact No: (330) 501-0694
Operating Hours:
Thursday–Saturday: 9 AM – 1 PM
Sunday–Wednesday: Closed
Youngstown Area Goodwill Industries
This Goodwill offers a wide variety of items, from furniture and clothes to electronics and kitchenware. The store is well-organized, and the aisles are spacious enough for you to shop without feeling tired. Prices are reasonable, and I’ve found some good brand-name products here.
One of my favorite sections is the glassware, it’s always stocked with vintage cups, plates, and other neat finds. Whether you’re looking for practical items or something unique, you’re likely to spot something worthwhile. It can get busy, especially on weekends, but the staff are always helpful and get you through checkout quickly.
If you’re not in a rush and take your time, you can score some great deals. I also like that they regularly put out new items, so it’s worth visiting often to see what’s been added. It’s a dependable spot if you’re looking for affordable, quality finds.
- Best for: Housewares, clothing, and home décor
- Not ideal for: Shoppers who want everything sorted by size or color
- My Top Picks: Vintage Pyrex, denim jackets, lamps
- Location:
Address: 2747 Belmont Ave #1864, Youngstown, OH 44505
Contact No: (330) 759-0677
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 9 AM – 8 PM
Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Angels Mission
Angels Mission is a small but interesting thrift store, and you never know what you’ll find each time you visit. They have a variety of items like racks of clothes, shelves full of toys, and bins with a huge selection of books. The prices are very affordable, and they often have sales or discounts going on, making it even easier to find a good deal.
The shop may not be huge, but it’s well-kept, and everything is easy to see and find. Even though it’s a smaller space, they make sure it’s organized, which makes shopping here a lot of fun. What stands out most to me is how quickly the inventory changes. One week, you might find a bunch of purses and accessories, and the next week, you could see shelves filled with wall art, lamps, and other interesting home décor.
It’s always different, and I enjoy the surprise each time I stop by. It’s the perfect spot for shoppers who enjoy looking through a variety of items and discovering unique finds. I always leave with something fun or useful that I wasn’t expecting.
- Best for: Affordable secondhand clothing and toys
- Not ideal for: People wanting a large furniture selection
- My Top Picks: Women’s blouses, toy sets, picture frames
- Location:
Address: 4527 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512
Operating Hours:
Tuesday, Thursday, Friday: 10:30 AM – 7 PM
Wednesday, Saturday: 10:30 AM – 6:30 PM
Sunday–Monday: Closed
St. Vincent de Paul Society
St. Vincent de Paul has a real community vibe, making it feel more like a place that cares than just a regular thrift store. They have a nice selection of clothes, home goods, and some furniture. The shop isn’t huge, but the prices are fantastic. Sometimes, they even give away items for free on certain days, especially for people who really need them, which adds to the feeling of goodwill here.
It’s clear that the store is there to help the community and not just make a profit. I’ve found some really useful things like baking dishes, barely worn jackets, and even a couple of small furniture pieces during my visits. The staff is always friendly and easygoing, and they help keep the atmosphere relaxed.
It’s easy to take your time and look around without feeling rushed. If you’re shopping on a tight budget or just want to find good deals, this store is definitely worth a stop. Whether you’re looking for something practical or just browsing, St. Vincent de Paul is a good place to check out.
- Best for: Basic household goods and clothing at low prices
- Not ideal for: Trendy or curated items
- My Top Picks: Coats, kitchen gadgets, backpacks
- Location:
Address: 317 Via Mt Carmel Ave, Youngstown, OH 44505
Contact No: (330) 333-3601
Operating Hours:
Monday, Saturday, Sunday: Closed
Tuesday–Friday: 9 AM – 5 PM
Consign & Design
This place stands out because it’s neat, bright, and organized, almost like a boutique. The items here are gently used, and the quality is better than what you usually find at most thrift stores. They offer a variety of clothes, handbags, furniture, and home décor.
The prices are fair for the condition of the items, making it a good spot for finding great deals. Plus, they often have seasonal items, so you can find something new depending on the time of year. I enjoy shopping here when I want something nice but don’t want to pay full retail price. You can tell that the store owners carefully select what they put out for sale.
It’s a more peaceful and laid-back shopping experience compared to some of the bigger, busier thrift stores. If you prefer shopping at a store where you can take your time and find quality items, this place is definitely worth visiting. The staff are friendly and happy to help if you need it, but they’re never pushy. You can easily spend a few hours here, enjoying the quiet atmosphere and discovering something special.
- Best for: Higher-end consignment clothing and décor
- Not ideal for: Bargain bin shoppers or bulk buyers
- My Top Picks: Designer purses, dining chairs, framed art
- Location:
Address: 11 W McKinley Way, Youngstown, OH 44514
Contact No: (330) 757-3633
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Vintage of 330
This store is all about vintage fashion, so if you love colorful jackets, bold prints, and retro accessories, this is the place to go. It’s perfect for anyone who wants to stand out and wear unique outfits that aren’t like what everyone else is wearing. The owner is really friendly and always ready to help, whether you need a specific size or want some suggestions on different styles to try.
They also have a good mix of sizes, so you won’t feel left out if you’re looking for something in particular. The store’s collection is carefully chosen, and you can tell that every item is picked with style in mind. While it doesn’t have a huge selection, everything is special, and it’s a great place for anyone who loves fashion that’s bold and different.
If you want something fun and unique for your wardrobe, this shop is perfect. You might even find some great accessories to complete a vintage look!
- Best for: Vintage lovers and creative dressers
- Not ideal for: Shoppers wanting everyday wear or kids’ clothes
- My Top Picks: Leather jackets, old band tees, retro sunglasses
- Location:
Address: 4400 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512
Contact No: (330) 980-2935
Operating Hours:
Tuesday–Saturday: 1 PM – 6 PM
Sunday–Monday: Closed
The Overstock Shoppe
The Overstock Shoppe is a quiet little store that offers home goods at a great price. While it’s not exactly a typical thrift shop, they still have a variety of items like bedding, small furniture, and kitchen tools at much lower prices than the big-box stores. If you’re looking to refresh your home or need some essentials, this place is definitely worth a look.
However, you won’t find clothes or other clothing-related items here, so it’s more focused on home supplies. Even though it’s a smaller shop, the items are clean and in good condition, often like new. I like to stop by when I need cookware, extra pillows, or just want to pick up something to add to my home.
The prices are reasonable, and they frequently update their inventory, so there’s always something different to check out. It’s a great spot if you want affordable home items without the hassle of shopping at larger stores.
- Best for: Discount home goods and kitchen basics
- Not ideal for: Clothes, books, or secondhand fashion
- My Top Picks: Sheet sets, organizers, mixing bowls
- Location:
Address: 3035 Belmont Ave, Youngstown, OH 44505
Contact No: (234) 855-0911
Operating Hours:
Wednesday, Thursday, Friday: 10 AM – 6 PM
Saturday: 10 AM – 4 PM
Sunday–Tuesday: Closed
Star Supply
Star Supply is a unique hardware store with more than just tools and nails. It’s packed with overstock items and unusual household finds that you wouldn’t expect to see in a typical hardware store. From toys and quirky home décor to off-season goods, there’s always something different.
The prices are pretty good, especially for items that you might not find in bigger stores. I’ve picked up some fun, unexpected things here, like a vintage clock and a cool outdoor light. The store isn’t the most organized, but that’s part of the fun.
You have to take your time and look carefully, but the hunt makes it interesting. If you enjoy browsing and discovering random, useful items for your home, this place is worth checking out. Whether you’re looking for practical goods or a quirky surprise, there’s something for everyone.
- Best for: Hardware deals and odd finds
- Not ideal for: Clothing, books, or furniture
- My Top Picks: Storage bins, offbeat decorations, tools
- Location:
Address: 875 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44502
Contact No: (330) 746-2969
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 8 AM – 4:30 PM
Sunday: 10 AM – 5 PM
Ms. Charolette’s “Resale” Boutique
Ms. Charolette’s “Resale” Boutique is a small but lovely shop that focuses on fashion. It doesn’t have a large number of racks, but everything on display is carefully selected and reasonably priced. The store has a boutique feel, making it a pleasant place to shop if you’re looking for something special.
The items are in great condition, and the owner is always there to greet you with a friendly smile. During one visit, I found a stylish purse and a nearly new pair of shoes at a fantastic price. The personalized service is what makes this shop stand out, the owner is always ready to help and offer suggestions.
It’s not the type of store where you’ll spend hours sifting through bins, but instead, it’s a great place to find a few carefully chosen, high-quality pieces in a relaxed, personal setting. If you enjoy shopping in smaller, unique places, Ms. Charolette’s is a spot you’ll want to check out.
- Best for: Boutique-style secondhand fashion
- Not ideal for: Furniture or large inventory
- My Top Picks: Purses, heels, and dress tops
- Location:
Address: 3623 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44507
Retro Ohio
Retro Ohio is a great place to find a mix of vintage and modern items. The shop is a bit smaller, but it’s packed with cool pieces like mid-century furniture, records, and old glassware. Everything is in good condition, and the store is organized, so it’s easy to browse. You’ll find a lot of unique items that you won’t see anywhere else.
I’ve picked up some great things here, like a classic record player and a few vinyl albums. The prices are a little higher than most thrift stores, but the quality of the items makes it worth it. The store has a lot of character, and the owner is friendly and knowledgeable.
If you love vintage style or want to add something special to your home, Retro Ohio is the place to visit. It’s perfect for anyone looking for a unique piece of history or a stylish addition to their collection.
- Best for: Vintage and antique lovers
- Not ideal for: Clothes or bargain hunting
- My Top Picks: Record players, retro glasses, wall art
- Location:
Address: 4170 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512
Contact No: (330) 779-1969
Operating Hours:
Friday–Saturday: 12 PM – 7 PM
Tuesday: 12 PM – 7 PM
Sunday–Monday, Wednesday–Thursday: Closed
Economy Furniture
Economy Furniture is a great spot for affordable furniture, offering both new and gently used pieces. Whether you’re looking for a sofa, dresser, or bed, you’ll find a good selection with lower prices than many traditional furniture stores. The staff are always friendly and ready to help you find exactly what you need.
In addition to furniture, they also have smaller home items like rugs, lamps, and décor, making it easy to add those finishing touches to any room. The store is well-organized, so it’s easy to walk through and find what you’re looking for without feeling overwhelmed.
It’s a solid choice if you’re on a budget and need quality furniture without spending a lot of money. I often stop by when I’m helping someone furnish a home or apartment. With a mix of new and used options, you’ll find something that fits your style and budget. Plus, the staff is always ready to answer any questions, making the whole shopping experience smooth and enjoyable.
- Best for: Discount furniture and large home items
- Not ideal for: Clothing or small resale goods
- My Top Picks: Sofas, dressers, end tables
- Location:
Address: 2828 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44507
Contact No: (330) 782-0331
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 9:30 AM – 5 PM
Saturday: 9:30 AM – 4 PM
Sunday: Closed
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrifting around Youngstown has introduced me to so many unique places, each with its own style and selection. Whether you’re shopping for budget-friendly furniture, vintage clothing, or quirky home decor, these local spots offer something different from the usual big stores. I hope this list helps you find a few new favorites and makes your next secondhand shopping trip more fun and rewarding.
