Best thrift stores in Mansfield offer a wide range of great deals, from clothing to home goods, making it a perfect spot for thrift lovers. Whether you’re looking for budget-friendly fashion, unique vintage finds, or everyday essentials, these stores have something for everyone. I love exploring these local places, as each one provides a different experience and a chance to score something special.
In this guide, I’ll share my personal experiences at some of the top thrift stores in Mansfield. From cozy, well-organized spaces to places with hidden gems, you’ll find a variety of options to suit your shopping style. So, grab your reusable bags and get ready to discover some amazing finds in Mansfield’s best thrift stores!
Best Thrift Shops in Mansfield – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What Goes ‘Round Thrift Shoppe | Small home goods, women’s tops | Big furniture or huge selection | Super affordable | Quiet, community feel | Weekday mornings |
| Volunteers of America | Everyday clothes, basic furniture | Rare vintage finds | Budget-friendly | Friendly, no-frills | Weekday afternoons |
| Addy’s Attic | Kids’ clothes, cozy sweaters | Large inventory | Very reasonable | Warm, supportive cause | Midweek (limited hours) |
| Ohio Thrift Store | Jackets, handbags, kitchenware | Deeply discounted furniture | Mixed bargains | Spacious, well-organized | Weekends (new restocks) |
| The New Store | New trendy clothes (event-based) | Walk-in thrifting | Event deals | Boutique, charity-focused | Check event schedule |
| Petit Tresor Boutique | Vintage furniture, DIY supplies | Modern mass-produced items | Mid-range vintage | Charming, curated | Weekend afternoons |
| A Heritage House | Gently used furniture, home decor | Large renovation pieces | Fair for quality | Neat, helpful staff | Weekday mornings |
| Amara’s 2nd Chances | Upscale coats, shoes, handbags | Bargain-bin prices | Pricier thrift | Clean, boutique-like | Weekday afternoons |
| Second Hand Music | Vinyl records, guitars, gear | Non-music items | Fair for collectors | Music-lover’s paradise | Anytime (great selection) |
| The Blue Tag Company | Jackets, small household items | High-end or rare finds | Very low-cost | Simple, no-fuss | Quick weekday stops |
| BUCKEYE THRIFT | Books, home essentials | Designer fashion | Wallet-friendly | Crowded but stocked | Weekday mornings |
| Goodwill | Everyday clothes, household items | Luxury brands | Affordable basics | Reliable, well-organized | Early mornings (less crowded) |
What Goes ‘Round Thrift Shoppe
This store may be small, but it’s very neat and well-kept. I love how everything is arranged by category, making it easy to find what I’m looking for. The shelves are always clean, and the space isn’t cluttered, so it’s a relaxing place to shop. What’s even better are the prices—everything, from clothes to household items, is surprisingly affordable.
It’s the perfect spot to browse without feeling rushed. The volunteers are kind and welcoming, always ready to offer help when needed. While it may not have the massive selection of larger thrift stores, What Goes ‘Round makes up for it with quality. I’ve found some great items here, like beautiful plates for my kitchen and gently used shirts for under $5 each.
It’s definitely a place I stop by when I’m in the downtown area, as it’s close and convenient. The store has a quiet, community-oriented feel, which makes it a nice break from the hustle and bustle. If you’re someone who enjoys supporting local spots and wants a calm thrifting experience, this store is a great choice. It’s easy to pop in, and you never know what you might find!
- Best for: Clean and quiet thrifting with helpful volunteers.
- Not ideal for: Large furniture or tons of clothing racks.
- My Top Picks: Dishes, small home goods, and women’s tops.
- Location Details:
Located in: Downtown Mansfield
Address: 115 N Main St, Mansfield, OH 44903
Contact No: (419) 522-2890
Operating Hours:
Monday–Friday: 10 AM–4 PM
Saturday: 10 AM–2 PM
Sunday: Closed
Volunteers of America Ohio & Indiana Thrift Store
Volunteers of America Thrift Store is one of my regular stops in Mansfield because it’s always stocked with a great selection of clothes and deals. Located inside the Kroger plaza, it’s convenient for me to pop in when I’m running errands. I love that they often have sales or color-tag discounts, which really help lower the prices.
The staff is always friendly, welcoming you with a smile every time you walk in. It’s one of those places where you feel comfortable shopping at your own pace without being overwhelmed. While you might not find one-of-a-kind treasures here, it’s perfect for finding basics or refreshing your wardrobe with affordable options.
I’ve got brand-name jeans, cozy sweaters, and even a few fun accessories for just a few bucks. They also have a small but decent selection of furniture in the back, which I often check out on my visits. It’s the kind of place that’s reliable for regular shopping needs, with great prices to match.
- Best for: Affordable clothing and quick finds during errands.
- Not ideal for: Rare vintage or high-end brands.
- My Top Picks: Denim, sweaters, and basic household furniture.
- Location Details:
Located in: Kroger Plaza
Address: 1280 Park Ave W, Mansfield, OH 44906
Contact No: (419) 528-3036
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 8 AM–8 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–6 PM
Addy’s Attic
Addy’s Attic is a lovely little thrift shop with a personal touch. You can really tell it’s run with care, and everything about the store feels warm and welcoming. Even though it’s smaller than some of the other thrift stores in town, the selection is well-curated, and the prices are incredibly reasonable.
What makes it even better is that most of the proceeds go to supporting local community programs, which adds an extra layer of meaning to every purchase. The atmosphere is peaceful and calm, perfect for shopping without any pressure. The staff here are friendly and kind, making your experience even more enjoyable.
This store isn’t the place for a huge shopping spree, but if you stop by when they restock, you’ll find some great gems. I’ve gotten a few cozy sweaters and a pair of gently worn boots here at excellent prices. Addy’s Attic is also a great place for kids’ clothes that are in really good condition. It’s a perfect stop if you’re looking for something small but special, while also supporting a good cause.
- Best for: Friendly atmosphere and supporting a cause.
- Not ideal for: Big inventory or furniture.
- My Top Picks: Boots, children’s wear, and warm sweaters.
- Location Details:
Address: 280 Marion Ave, Mansfield, OH 44903
Contact No: (567) 370-0932
Operating Hours:
Tuesday–Friday: 10 AM–4 PM
Saturday–Monday: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Stores In Newark
Ohio Thrift Store
Ohio Thrift Store is a great spot for anyone looking to spend some time hunting for deals. The store is always tidy, and there’s a wide variety of clothing and home items to choose from. Located in the Appleseed Center, it’s easy to get lost in the aisles for an hour or more as you browse through everything they have.
The staff are friendly, and they’re always ready to assist if you’re looking for something specific. I’ve found some excellent brand-name jackets for under $10 here, which was a nice surprise. While this is a solid all-around thrift store, I’ve noticed that their pricing can vary quite a bit. Some items are priced very low, while others might be a little more than you’d expect.
However, if you don’t mind doing a little digging, you can definitely find great deals. They get frequent restocks, so I try to swing by once or twice a month to see what’s new. It’s a place where you can always find something special with a bit of patience.
- Best for: Large clothing section and frequent new items.
- Not ideal for: Consistent pricing or deeply discounted furniture.
- My Top Picks: Jackets, handbags, and kitchenware.
- Location Details:
Located in: Appleseed Center
Address: 1436 Lexington Ave, Mansfield, OH 44906
Contact No: (419) 709-8943
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–9 PM
Sunday: 10 AM–8 PM
The New Store
The New Store in Mansfield is more of a nonprofit boutique, but it stands out with its focus on new clothing for local families. The shop is beautifully organized, and the selection is filled with modern, stylish pieces you might not typically find in traditional thrift stores. Their mission to help children in need is something I really appreciate, and the quality of items is always top-notch.
They also host occasional public shopping events or fundraisers, which is a nice way to support the community while picking up something fresh for yourself. That said, because of its nonprofit focus, it’s not the type of store you can just wander into at any time. It’s better to check out their event schedule or call ahead to make sure they’re open for public shopping.
I’ve attended one of their pop-up sales before, and everything was new, with prices so low, it felt like a steal. If you’re someone who likes to give back while snagging some great items, this is definitely a place you should check out.
- Best for: Community-focused new clothing and fundraisers.
- Not ideal for: Walk-in thrifting or secondhand furniture.
- My Top Picks: Trendy new clothes and event deals.
- Location Details:
Address: 890 W 4th St, Mansfield, OH 44906
Contact No: (419) 565-7505
Operating Hours: Based on events; call ahead for info
Related: Best Thrift Shops in Lakewood
Petit Tresor Boutique Mansfield
Petit Tresor is a charming little boutique that’s perfect for anyone who loves vintage and upcycled items. The store features an amazing selection of antique furniture, from classic pieces to unique finds with a story to tell. What I enjoy most is browsing their collection of handmade or restored pieces, it’s easy to discover something that’s not only practical but has its own special character.
They also carry Dixie Belle products, which are perfect for DIY projects or furniture makeovers if you’re into that kind of thing. The store may be small, but it feels very personalized, and the staff is always welcoming and helpful. I’ve found some really interesting items here, like vintage dressers and quirky home decor pieces that add so much personality to my space.
If you’re looking for something that stands out and has a bit of history behind it, Petit Tresor is definitely worth checking out. It’s the kind of place that makes every visit feel like a delightful little discovery.
- Best for: Vintage furniture and DIY supplies.
- Not ideal for: Mass-produced or modern home goods.
- My Top Picks: Upcycled furniture and antiques.
- Location Details:
Address: 1680 S Main St, Mansfield, OH 44907
Contact No: (419) 522-1225
Operating Hours:
Tuesday–Saturday: 10 AM–5 PM
Sunday–Monday: Closed
A Heritage House Furniture-Gifts
If you’re in the market for gently used furniture, this store is a great spot to check out. They have a nice mix of unique pieces, from cozy sofas to stylish dining sets, all priced reasonably. Beyond furniture, they also offer a variety of gifts, home decor, and small household items.
The store is always neat and well-organized, making it easy to browse and find something to spruce up your living space. I’ve picked up a few great items here that added just the right touch to my home. While the selection is great, it is a smaller shop, so you might not always find exactly what you’re looking for on the first visit.
However, the quality of the items is consistently good, and I’ve always had positive experiences with the staff. They’re friendly and more than happy to help, especially when it comes to loading a new piece of furniture into your car. It’s definitely worth a stop if you’re looking for something special to add to your home.
- Best for: Gently used furniture and home decor.
- Not ideal for: Large-scale renovation items or mass-produced furniture.
- My Top Picks: Sofas, dining tables, and unique decor.
- Location Details:
Address: 1170 Lexington Ave, Mansfield, OH 44907
Contact No: (419) 571-1948
Operating Hours:
Tuesday–Friday: 9 AM–6 PM
Saturday–Monday: Closed
Amara’s 2nd Chances Premier Resale Store
This store feels like a secret place in Mansfield, offering a fantastic selection of upscale resale items. They specialize in unique clothing finds for men, women, and children, with something for everyone. The store is always clean and well-organized, and I’ve noticed that the items are generally in excellent condition.
I appreciate how they arrange everything neatly, so I can easily find what I’m looking for. The staff here is always friendly and willing to help if I need assistance or am searching for something specific, but they also give me space to explore at my own pace. Though it’s a bit pricier than typical thrift stores, I think the quality and variety of items make it worth the extra cost.
The store frequently has new arrivals, so there’s always something fresh to check out. I’ve picked up high-quality coats, stylish shoes, and even some great handbags here for a good price. They also have a nice selection of accessories, like scarves and hats, that can add a little something special to any outfit. If you’re in the area, it’s definitely worth stopping by to see what new items they have in stock.
- Best for: Upscale secondhand clothing and accessories.
- Not ideal for: Budget thrifting or bargain hunters.
- My Top Picks: Coats, shoes, and handbags.
- Location Details:
Address: 1060 Park Ave W, Mansfield, OH 44906
Contact No: (419) 378-2587
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 12–5 PM
Sunday: Closed
Second Hand Music
For music lovers, Second Hand Music is a must-visit spot in Mansfield! Whether you’re a vinyl enthusiast or just looking for a new instrument, they offer a great variety of affordable options. The store has everything from old records to guitars, amps, and other music equipment.
I’ve spent hours here searching through classic albums and occasionally stumble upon something rare that I wasn’t expecting. It’s a real treat to find hidden gems, especially if you’re into collecting records or trying out new instruments. The store may be small, but it’s extremely well-organized, and you can tell the owners really care about what they stock.
The layout makes it easy to find exactly what you’re looking for, whether you’re after a specific album or a piece of equipment. They also have knowledgeable staff who are always happy to help with questions or offer recommendations. If you’re into music and love the idea of finding secondhand deals, Second Hand Music is a fun and rewarding stop.
- Best for: Vinyl records, music gear, and instruments.
- Not ideal for: Non-music-related items or large furniture.
- My Top Picks: Vinyl records, guitars, and music accessories.
- Location Details:
Address: 740 Olivesburg Rd, Mansfield, OH 44905
Contact No: (567) 241-9223
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
Sunday: Closed
The Blue Tag Company LLC
The Blue Tag Company might not have the huge selection of some of the larger stores in town, but it’s still worth a visit if you’re looking for an affordable deal. The store carries a mix of clothing, home goods, and sometimes electronics. I’ve found everything from simple shirts to a few interesting home decor pieces without spending a lot of money.
The store might not always be packed with items, but you can usually find something practical or unique if you’re willing to browse a bit. It’s a perfect place if you’re on a budget but still want to find something nice. While you won’t find high-end items or rare treasures, the Blue Tag Company is great for everyday shopping.
The prices are very reasonable, and I often find things I can use right away. It’s not a place to spend hours hunting for a specific item, but you can stop by and find exactly what you need without spending much time or money. The store is small, but it’s neatly organized, so it’s easy to quickly look through everything. If you’re in the area and need to pick up something practical, this place is an easy, budget-friendly option.
- Best for: Everyday items and quick thrifting.
- Not ideal for: Vintage or higher-end finds.
- My Top Picks: Jackets, small household items, and electronics.
- Location Details:
Address: 303 N Trimble Rd, Mansfield, OH 44906
BUCKEYE THRIFT
If you’re on the lookout for a bargain, BUCKEYE THRIFT is a great spot to explore. They offer a wide range of items, from clothing and shoes to books and household goods, and the selection changes frequently. I’ve managed to pick up everything from kitchen gadgets to comfy sweaters, all for really affordable prices.
The book section is one of my favorite parts of the store. Whether you’re into novels, cookbooks, or kids’ books, you’re sure to find something interesting. The prices are always low, which makes it easy to walk out with multiple items without worrying about your budget. The store is generally well-organized, making it easy to search through everything, though it can get a little crowded, especially on weekends.
Even so, it’s worth stopping by if you’re after some great finds. They always seem to have new items in stock, and I’ve discovered plenty of hidden gems just by taking the time to look. If you’re in the area and want to grab some books or home essentials at a bargain, BUCKEYE THRIFT is definitely worth checking out.
- Best for: Books, household items, and budget finds.
- Not ideal for: High-end fashion or rare vintage items.
- My Top Picks: Books and home essentials.
- Location Details:
Address: 1411 Park Ave W, Mansfield, OH 44903
Contact No: (419) 775-7192
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 10 AM–6 PM
Sunday: 11 AM–5 PM
Goodwill Industries
Goodwill in Mansfield is a trusted spot for thrift shoppers, and it definitely lives up to its reputation. The store is always clean, and the layout makes it easy to find what you’re looking for. They have a great mix of clothing, shoes, accessories, and household items, so it’s a one-stop shop for many of your needs.
The prices are affordable, and I’ve picked up some amazing deals on clothes, especially when I’m patient enough to go through the racks. It’s always exciting because you never know when you’ll stumble across something great, whether it’s a pair of jeans for $3 or a kitchen appliance for just a few bucks.
One of the things that makes this Goodwill stand out is the helpful and friendly staff. They always greet you with a smile and are willing to help if you need it. The store is well-kept, so it’s never overwhelming to browse. I’ve found everything from gently used furniture to kitchenware and even some fun decor pieces.
It’s perfect for picking up daily essentials, but you can also find a few surprises if you take your time. Whether you’re looking for something specific or just browsing, this Goodwill offers good quality for a great price.
- Best for: Affordable clothing and everyday items.
- Not ideal for: High-end designer pieces or rare collectibles.
- My Top Picks: Clothing and small household items.
- Location Details:
Address: 1280 Lexington Ave, Mansfield, OH 44906
Contact No: (567) 215-0200
Operating Hours:
Monday–Saturday: 9 AM–8 PM
Sunday: 10 AM–6 PM
FAQS
Conclusion
In conclusion, Mansfield offers a variety of thrift stores that cater to all kinds of shoppers. Whether you’re looking for affordable clothing, unique home items, or something special, you’ll find plenty of options to explore. Each store has its vibe, but they all share one thing in common and great deals! So, the next time you’re in the area, be sure to stop by these local thrift shops and see what hidden treasures you can uncover. Happy thrifting!
