Elkhart has many great places for thrift shopping. Whether you’re looking for clothes, home items, or old treasures, there’s something for everyone. The best thrift stores in Elkhart have good prices, friendly people, and a wide mix of items. Some stores are big with tons of stuff, while others are small and cozy. No matter what you’re hunting for, you’ll enjoy the fun of finding a good deal.
In this guide, I’ll share my favorite thrift stores around town. Each one has its own style and special finds. I’ve visited these places myself, so I’ll tell you what they’re best for and what to expect. I’ll also include hours, phone numbers, and addresses to help you plan your visit. Let’s dive into the best spots to thrift in Elkhart!
Best Thrift Shops in Elkhart – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Price | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thrift at Woodland Crossing | Clean, budget-friendly items | Big furniture/tools | Very affordable | Calm, welcoming | Weekday mornings |
| Faith Mission Thrift Store | Bargain clothes & home goods | Designer/luxury items | Super cheap | Simple, no-frills | Weekdays (restocks often) |
| STASH Boutique Consignment | Trendy women’s fashion | Men’s clothes/furniture | Mid-range | Upscale boutique | Weekends (new arrivals) |
| Bargain Wright Thrift Store | New overstock & home goods | Vintage/antiques | Low prices | Bright, organized | Weekdays (daily restocks) |
| Thrift at Emma’s Treasures | Vintage & household items | Highly organized shopping | Cheap | Cozy, eclectic | Weekends (more selection) |
| Hart City Resale Mall | Variety & vintage finds | Quick shopping | Bargains | Treasure-hunt vibe | Weekends (busy but fun) |
| Shepherd’s Cove Clothing Pantry | Free clothes for all ages | Non-clothing items | Free | Warm, community-focused | Wed evenings/Fri mornings |
| Bargain Hunters Paradise | Brand-name discounts | Vintage/antiques | Steep discounts | Cheerful, busy | Early weekdays (shorter lines) |
| The Same As It Never Was | Quality furniture/decor | Clothing/accessories | Fair deals | Friendly, tidy | Weekdays (less crowded) |
| Fresh Start Flea Market | Hidden gems & collectibles | Large furniture | Affordable | Charming, personal | Weekends (relaxed browsing) |
| Goodwill | Books, clothes, housewares | Antiques/furniture | Budget-friendly | Clean, organized | Mornings (restocked daily) |
| Elkhart Flea Market | Bargain digs & odd finds | Upscale shopping | Very low | Laid-back, rustic | Weekends (best selection) |
Thrift at Woodland Crossing
Thrift at Woodland Crossing is a small and peaceful thrift shop that feels clean and welcoming. The people working there were friendly, and the whole place had a calm and easy vibe. It was simple to walk around and look through the racks and shelves. They had a mix of things like clothes, house decorations, and fun little seasonal items. Prices were low, and you can tell the workers care about the store and its mission.
One thing I really liked was knowing that when I buy something here, I’m helping other people and the planet. This shop supports MCC, which helps with local and global relief and peace projects. That makes shopping here feel even more special. If you enjoy looking for good deals and helping a good cause, this is one of the best thrift stores in Elkhart, Indiana. It’s a good place to visit if you want a quiet, nice shopping trip with some great finds.
- Best for: Clean, well-priced secondhand items
- Not ideal for: Big furniture or heavy tools
- My top picks: Tableware, casual clothing, small home items
- Location details:
📍 138 W Hively Ave #7, Elkhart, IN 46517
📞 (574) 326-3674
🕒 Mon–Sat: 10 AM–5 PM, Sun: Closed
Faith Mission Thrift Store
Faith Mission Thrift Store is one of those well-known second hand stores in Elkhart, Indiana where you can always find something different. That’s part of the fun! The prices are really affordable, and I’ve found some great clothes, dishes, and small home items here. Many people come to this shop just to enjoy the hunt or to find things to resell for a profit.
The store is plain and simple inside, but the people who work here are kind and helpful. They bring out new stuff often, so it’s worth checking back often. I’ve found many good items here without spending a lot of money. It’s a great place for shoppers who want to save money and find rare items.
- Best for: Everyday clothes and bargain finds
- Not ideal for: Designer or luxury items
- My top picks: Jackets, kids’ clothes, glassware
- Location details:
📍 335 La Salle St, Elkhart, IN 46516
📞 (574) 293-3406
🕒 Mon: 9 AM–4 PM, Tue–Fri: 9 AM–5 PM, Sat: 9 AM–4 PM, Sun: Closed
Related: Best Thrift Shops in Columbus Indiana
STASH Boutique Consignment
STASH Boutique Consignment is one of the best consignment shops in Elkhart, Indiana if you love fashion and nice clothes. The store is clean and neat, and the clothes are really stylish and well-kept. I saw brand names like Coach and Michael Kors, but the prices were way lower than what you’d pay at the mall. Everything looked new and felt fancy.
The shop owner was kind and welcoming, and the store itself felt more like a cute boutique than a secondhand shop. They also sell nice shoes, jewelry, and bags that are great for adding to your wardrobe. If you want to look good without spending too much, this is a great place to stop by. It’s perfect for anyone who likes dressing up or looking for something unique.
- Best for: Trendy and upscale women’s fashion
- Not ideal for: Men’s clothing or furniture
- My top picks: Designer handbags, heels, unique jewelry
- Location details:
📍 118 S Main St, Elkhart, IN 46516
📞 (574) 389-7446
🕒 Mon–Fri: 10 AM–5:30 PM, Sat: 10 AM–4 PM, Sun: Closed
Bargain Wright Thrift Store
Bargain Wright is one of the most popular and top rated thrift stores in Elkhart, Indiana because it sells both used and brand-new items. This shop is not your regular thrift store. It has clearance items, overstock products, and some secondhand stuff all in one place. I found new kitchen tools, tools for the garage, and cool decorations for my home, all for really low prices.
What makes it even better is that part of your purchase goes toward helping teachers and schools in the area. That made me feel good about shopping here. They bring out new items every day, so it’s always different each time you go. If you like to find good deals and support the community, this shop is a great choice.
- Best for: Liquidation items and home goods
- Not ideal for: Vintage or antique lovers
- My top picks: Tarps, cookware, everyday essentials
- Location details:
📍 3700 Cassopolis St, Elkhart, IN 46514
📞 (574) 564-0193
🕒 Tue–Fri: 10 AM–5 PM, Sat: 10 AM–4 PM, Sun: 11 AM–3 PM, Mon: Closed
Thrift at Emma’s Treasures
Thrift at Emma’s Treasures is one of the more fun and interesting thrift shops Elkhart, Indiana has for people who love secondhand shopping. The store is big and full of many different types of items. There are clothes, furniture, books, home goods, and sometimes vintage stuff too. Prices were super low, and I kept finding more cool things the longer I stayed.
Emma, the shop owner, was very sweet and made me feel welcome. I loved how the store had a cozy feel but was still packed with great stuff. If you like to dig around and find fun surprises, this is the shop for you. It’s great for people who like variety and want something new each time they visit.
- Best for: Vintage finds and household goods
- Not ideal for: People who want super-organized racks
- My top picks: Books, seasonal decor, funky kitchenware
- Location details:
📍 1632 S Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46516
📞 (574) 444-8800
🕒 Sun: 10 AM–7 PM, Mon–Sat: 10 AM–5 PM
Hart City Resale Mall
Hart City is one of those places where you can spend a long time just looking around. It’s a big resale store full of all kinds of things, furniture, old items, kitchen stuff, clothes, and even toys. I always feel like I’m going on a small treasure hunt when I visit. The prices are affordable, and the space is clean and easy to walk through. You never really know what you’ll find here, but the trip is almost always worth it.
If you enjoy looking for bargains and like having lots of choices, this market won’t let you down. They also have brand-name clearance items and some cool old pieces. It’s one of the top rated thrift stores in Elkhart, Indiana because of its big variety and low prices. I especially enjoy their outdoor flea market when the weather is nice. Bring cash, wear comfy shoes, and take your time—there’s plenty to see.
- Best for: Variety and vintage finds
- Not ideal for: Fast in-and-out shopping
- My top picks: Antique furniture, power tools, vintage decor
- Location details:
📍 2301 S Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46517
📞 (574) 293-0133
🕒 Sun 10AM–7PM, Mon Closed, Tue–Thu 11AM–6PM, Fri–Sat 10AM–7PM
Shepherd’s Cove Clothing Pantry
Shepherd’s Cove is more than just a clothing store, it’s a kind and giving place that helps people. Everything here is free, and they still have a pretty big selection. The volunteers are very nice and welcoming, and the store is neat and well arranged. They have clothes for babies, children, men, and women, plus shoes and sometimes even toys. It’s the kind of place that reminds you how caring some people can be.
This place stands out from other second hand stores in Elkhart, Indiana because of its mission to help. I’ve seen parents find winter coats for their children and others walk out with full outfits, all for free. Just remember they are only open a few times a week, so you’ll want to check the hours before going. It’s a special place for anyone who needs a little support.
- Best for: Free clothes and community support
- Not ideal for: Buying furniture or household items
- My top picks: Kids’ clothes, shoes, and volunteer-run events
- Location details:
📍 347 W Lusher Ave, Elkhart, IN 46517
📞 (574) 226-0261
🕒 Wed 5PM–7:30PM, Fri 10AM–12:30PM, all other days closed
Bargain Hunters Paradise
Bargain Hunters Paradise is located inside the Hart City Flea Market, but it feels like its own store. If you’re trying to save money, this is the place to check out. Their motto is “Never Pay Retail,” and they really stick to it. You can find brand-name items from big stores at prices way lower than usual, sometimes up to 90% off. The store is clean, cheerful, and simple to shop in.
They sell a little bit of everything, tools, electronics, toys, and home goods. For anyone looking for the best thrift stores in Elkhart, this place is great for budget-friendly new and used stuff. Sometimes the checkout line can get long because it’s a busy spot, but the good deals are worth waiting for. It’s always a fun stop if you love getting great prices.
- Best for: New and discounted brand-name items
- Not ideal for: Finding older vintage pieces
- My top picks: Electronics, tools, kids’ toys
- Location details:
📍 2301 S Nappanee St, Elkhart, IN 46517
📞 (574) 293-0133
🕒 Sun 10AM–5PM, Mon–Sat 10AM–7PM
Fresh Start Flea Market
Fresh Start Flea Market is a smaller store but full of charm. It’s one of those shops where the owners truly care and want every customer to feel welcome. The store has a little bit of everything, decor, small furniture, toys, and collectibles, and the prices are just right. It’s a warm and friendly place where I almost always find something cool or unique.
If you enjoy looking for deals and like the feel of a personal touch, this store is a great place to visit. It feels more relaxed than bigger resale stores Elkhart, Indiana has, and the good customer service makes it even better. My kids love going here too because there’s always something fun to explore. It’s become one of my favorite little markets in town.
- Best for: Unique finds and friendly service
- Not ideal for: Large furniture shopping
- My top picks: Collectibles, toys, small furniture
- Location details:
📍 722 W Bristol St, Elkhart, IN 46514
📞 (574) 214-4862
🕒 Tue–Sat 10AM–6PM, Sun 10AM–6PM, Mon Closed
Goodwill Community Career Center
Goodwill Community Career Center is one of the more well-known thrift stores in Elkhart, Indiana, and for good reason. The store is very clean, with wide aisles and well-organized shelves. I always notice how neat everything looks, especially the book section, which is kept in great shape thanks to their friendly staff. It’s easy to shop here whether you’re hunting for clothes, housewares, or something unexpected. They have a wide mix of items at prices that are usually lower than most retail stores.
What I like most about this Goodwill is how often they restock. Every visit feels a little different, which makes it fun to return often. They also offer job and career services in the same location, which is a nice bonus for the community. This place is not just about finding a good deal, it’s also about giving people new chances. You’ll almost always find something useful or fun when you stop by.
- Best for: Clothing, books, and housewares
- Not ideal for: Furniture or antique shopping
- My top picks: Coats, kitchen sets, and used books
- Location details:
📍 3808 E Mishawaka Rd, Elkhart, IN 46517
📞 (574) 875-5068
🕒 Sun 11AM–6PM, Mon–Fri 9AM–8PM, Sat 8AM–8PM
The Same As It Never Was
This store has a fun name and a nice mix of home items and furniture. The Same As It Never Was mostly sells secondhand furniture, home appliances, and decorations. Every time I stop in, there’s always something different to see, like lamps, couches, tables, or artwork. The store is tidy, the owner is friendly, and the prices are very fair for what you get.
What makes this place special is the good quality of the items. Everything is gently used and still in great shape, and they have a mix of styles to match different tastes. If you’re looking for furniture thrift stores in Elkhart, Indiana, this one is a must-visit. Whether you just moved or want to freshen up your home, you’ll probably find something that works for your space and your wallet.
- Best for: Quality furniture and home decor
- Not ideal for: Clothing or small accessories
- My top picks: Sofas, lamps, framed artwork
- Location details:
📍 637 W Beardsley Ave, Elkhart, IN 46514
📞 (574) 606-4493
🕒 Mon–Wed 9AM–5PM, Thu 10AM–4PM, Fri 10AM–7PM, Sat 10AM–5PM, Sun Closed
Elkhart Flea Market
Elkhart Flea Market is a laid-back spot where you never really know what you’ll find until you walk in. This is one of those second hand stores in Elkhart, Indiana that has a little bit of everything, furniture, clothes, tools, and household goods. The prices are very fair, and the people working there are friendly and helpful. It’s not a fancy place, but that’s part of its charm. You just dig around until something catches your eye.
I like stopping here when I have extra time because the selection can surprise you. Some days you’ll find almost-new items, and other days it’s full of cool vintage things. It’s not the biggest place, but it makes up for that with low prices and fun browsing. If you enjoy a good hunt and don’t mind digging a bit, you’ll probably leave with something great.
- Best for: Bargain finds and mixed merchandise
- Not ideal for: Organized or upscale shopping
- My top picks: Tools, home decor, vintage odds and ends
- Location details:
📍 1681 Toledo Rd, Elkhart, IN 46516
📞 (574) 320-6695
🕒 Sun 10AM–5PM, Wed–Sat 10AM–6PM, Mon–Tue Closed
FAQS
Conclusion
Thrift shopping in Elkhart is a fun and budget-friendly way to find great stuff. From clothes and furniture to vintage treasures and everyday items, these local stores have so much to offer. Each shop has its own charm, and you never know what you’ll come across. Whether you’re a regular thrift shopper or just starting out, these places are worth a visit. So grab a friend, take your time, and enjoy the hunt, you might just find your next favorite thing!
