The best thrift stores in Erie are full of great surprises, from old-school furniture to trendy clothes you won’t find in regular stores. These shops are perfect whether you’re a long-time thrift shopper or just trying it out for the first time. Every store has something different, like cool vintage pieces, cheap prices, or friendly people who love to help. You never know what you’ll find, and that’s what makes it fun. Plus, shopping here means you’re saving money and supporting local businesses too.
If you love the thrill of discovering unique pieces or snagging a bargain, Erie’s thrift shops won’t disappoint. From stylish clothes and accessories to vintage furniture and home decor, the options are endless. A lot of these stores are in hidden neighborhoods, so you get to see more of Erie while looking for your next cool find. Whether you’re after a wardrobe refresh or hunting for the perfect vintage decor, you’re sure to leave these stores with something special.
Best Thrift Shops in Erie – Quick Overview
| Store Name | Best For | Not Ideal For | Vibe | Best Time to Visit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cobb’s Second Time Around Thrift Shop | Budget-friendly clothing, home goods | High-end designer items | Friendly, neighborhood feel | Weekday afternoons |
| Finders Keepers Of Erie | Quality secondhand clothing, home decor | Furniture or large items | Clean, classy | Weekends |
| Thrifter Heaven Thrift Store | Affordable clothing, books, small decor | High-end brands | Cozy, laid-back | Saturdays |
| Green Scene Thrift Store | Sustainable clothing, housewares | Large furniture | Calm, eco-conscious | Weekday mornings |
| Claudine’s | Vintage dresses, home decor | Modern brand names | Charming, curated | Weekends |
| Mel & Tee’s Secondhand & Estate Sales | Vintage clothing, collectibles | Modern home decor | Organized, friendly | Weekday afternoons |
| The Sassy Peacock | Designer clothing, accessories | Furniture or home goods | Boutique, stylish | Weekdays |
| City Mission Shop and Drop Off | Furniture, household bargains | Brand-new/high-end items | Community-focused | Weekday mornings |
| Rainbow Connection Thrift Store | Budget clothes, small household items | Large furniture | Simple, no-frills | Weekday afternoons |
| The Dollhouse At Pointe Foure Boutique | Vintage dresses, statement decor | Everyday basics | Elegant, curated | Weekends |
| Oregon Antiques | Antique furniture, collectibles | Modern mass-produced items | Nostalgic, organized | Weekends |
| Sharp Consignments, LLC | Gently used furniture, home goods | High-end designer brands | Practical, spacious | Weekday afternoons |
| Vintage Wonderland and Curiosity Shop | Retro decor, quirky finds | Modern/minimalist shoppers | Eclectic, fun | Weekends |
| Presque Isle Militaria, Antiques | Military memorabilia, rare collectibles | General clothing/home goods | Historical, niche | Thursday-Saturday afternoons |
| Cauldron & Thorne | Crystals, metaphysical items | Traditional thrift shoppers | Mystical, serene | Weekday afternoons |
| Bitty Bungalow Project | Upcycled furniture, unique clothing | Brand-new items | Creative, cozy | Weekends |
Best Budget-Friendly Thrift Stores in Erie
Cobb’s Second Time Around Thrift Shop
Cobb’s Second Time Around is one of the best thrift shops in Erie PA if you love a good variety. I always find something new every time I go in, whether it’s cozy sweaters, glassware, or small home decor. The store is clean and nicely set up, which makes it easy to look around without feeling overwhelmed.
Prices are fair too, which is great if you’re on a budget like me. It’s the kind of place where you can walk in with twenty dollars and leave with a bag full of stuff. One thing I really enjoy about Cobb’s is how friendly the workers are. They’re always happy to chat or help you find something specific.
It feels more like a neighborhood shop than a big store, which makes the shopping experience even better. I’ve found vintage mugs, cool t-shirts, and even some useful kitchen gadgets here. It’s perfect for people looking for good deals and simple treasures.
- Best for: Budget-friendly finds, secondhand clothing, home goods
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for high-end designer items or specific brand names
- My Top Picks: Clothes, small furniture, and unique home decor items
- Location: 1215 Parade St, Erie, PA 16503
- Phone: (814) 455-4068
- Operating Hours:
- Monday – Saturday: 10 AM – 6 PM
- Sunday: Closed
Thrifter Heaven Thrift Store
Thrifter Heaven is one of those places that really lives up to its name. It’s one of the cheap thrift stores Erie PA, shoppers love for scoring great deals. I found a cozy sweater here for just a few bucks and even picked up a couple of gently used books. The store might be on the smaller side, but it’s full of interesting stuff like dishes, wall art, and even a few small pieces of furniture.
Everything is priced low, which makes it easy to shop without guilt. The staff here are super friendly and always happy to help if you’re looking for something specific. I really like how relaxed and welcoming the place feels.
Even though it’s small, I never feel rushed or crowded. You can take your time and dig around for treasures, which is what I love most about thrift shopping. Every visit feels like a little adventure, and I always walk away with something cool.
- Best for: Affordable secondhand clothing, small home goods, books
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for high-end or designer brands
- My Top Picks: Clothing, books, and home decor
- Location: 4455 W Ridge Rd, Erie, PA 16506
- Phone: (814) 835-3365
- Operating Hours:
- Thursday & Tuesday: 2 PM – 6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM–2 PM
- Closed on Wednesdays, Friday, Sunday & Monday
Related: Best Thrift Shops in Reading
Rainbow Connection Thrift Store
Rainbow Connection is one of the best thrift stores in Erie PA, for those on the hunt for great deals without breaking the bank. This cozy little shop offers a mix of clothing, household goods, and even unique gifts at incredibly affordable prices. It’s the perfect place to find unique items while keeping your budget in check.
Whether you’re shopping for yourself or hunting for a special gift, there’s always something interesting to discover. The store’s welcoming atmosphere makes it easy to browse and find exactly what you need.
The staff is friendly and always willing to help, making your shopping experience enjoyable. With its well-organized shelves and budget-friendly prices, Rainbow Connection is a great spot to visit whenever you’re in the mood for thrifting on a budget.
- Best for: Budget-friendly clothing, small household items
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for large furniture or upscale items
- My Top Picks: Clothes, toys, and small kitchen items
- Location: 1516 Buffalo Rd, Erie, PA 16510
- Phone: (814) 453-4080
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 11 AM – 3 PM
- Closed on Saturdays and Sundays
Best Curated Consignment & Boutique-Style Thrift Shops
Claudine’s
Claudine’s is a small shop that is like a treasure chest full of great vintage and modern finds. It’s one of those vintage thrift stores in Erie PA that blends charm with good taste. I’ve come across gorgeous lamps, pretty wall art, and some trendy jackets here that you’d expect to pay a lot more for elsewhere.
The shop has a warm, welcoming feel that makes you want to take your time and really dig into every section. You can tell the items are picked with care, and everything is super clean. What stands out most about Claudine’s is how easy it is to find something that feels special.
The shelves are stocked with unique home pieces that give your space personality, and the clothes rack always has a few standout items worth trying. The prices are more than fair for the quality you’re getting. The friendly staff really add to the charm, making the whole visit feel personal and relaxed.
- Best for: Affordable vintage finds, home decor, and clothing
- Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking large furniture or more modern brand names
- My Top Picks: Vintage dresses, home decor, and unique accessories
- Location: 2208 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 873-2292
Finders Keepers Of Erie
Finders Keepers is one of my favorite spots when it comes to the best consignment shops in Erie, PA. It’s small but packed with really nice items that look almost new. I’ve found name-brand clothes, pretty dishes, and a few fun pieces of art for my walls. The store feels clean and classy, and everything is set up in a way that makes it easy to shop.
The prices are fair too, especially for the quality you get. What I love most is the mix of vintage style and modern finds. It’s a great place to go when you want something different without spending too much.
The people who work there are friendly and always greet you with a smile, which makes the visit even better. I stop by often just to see what’s new and usually walk out with something I didn’t know I needed. It’s perfect for shoppers who enjoy stylish secondhand shopping without digging through piles.
- Best for: Quality secondhand clothing, unique home decor
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for furniture or larger items
- My Top Picks: Vintage clothing, kitchenware, and decorative items
- Location: 1250 Brown Ave, Erie, PA 16502
- Phone: (814) 461-6424
- Operating Hours:
- Tuesday – Friday: 10 AM – 6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Closed on Mondays and Sundays
Best Clothing Thrift Stores in Erie PA
Green Scene Thrift Store
Green Scene is one of my favorite spots when I want to shop smart and stay eco-friendly. It’s one of the best thrift stores in Erie PA for finding quality secondhand clothes and housewares without breaking the bank. The store is clean, and everything is set up in a way that’s easy to look through.
I found a cute jacket here that looked brand new and only paid a few dollars for it. It’s a great place to visit when you want to stretch your budget and still get something nice. What I really love is how this store supports sustainable shopping. You’re not just buying used items, you’re helping reduce waste.
They always seem to have a new mix of things, like picture frames, glassware, and even some fun vintage finds. The layout makes browsing stress-free, and the calm vibe inside makes me want to take my time and enjoy the hunt. Every visit feels fresh, like you might find something totally different from the last time.
- Best for: Sustainable shopping, clothing, small home decor
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for larger furniture items
- My Top Picks: Eco-friendly clothing, housewares, and holiday decor
- Location: 1301 E Grandview Blvd, Erie, PA 16504
- Phone: (814) 580-1074
- Operating Hours:
- Tuesday & Thursday: 11 AM – 6 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM – 3 PM
- Closed on Wednesday, Friday, Sunday & Monday
Related: Best Thrift Stores In Bethlehem
Best Furniture and Home Goods Thrift Stores in Erie PA
Mel & Tee’s Secondhand & Estate Sales
Mel & Tee’s is a secret spot for anyone who loves hunting for quality secondhand treasures. Whether you’re into clothing thrift stores in Erie PA or you’re searching for quirky home decor, this place has it all. The store is well-organized, making it easy to spot something interesting on every shelf.
I’ve found everything from vintage jackets to unique trinkets that add character to my space. Plus, the prices are hard to beat, which makes it a top spot for budget-conscious shoppers. The friendly staff really enhances the experience here, offering helpful suggestions without being pushy.
It’s one of those places where you can truly enjoy the hunt, knowing that there’s always something new to discover. Whether you’re after a statement piece for your home or a new wardrobe addition, Mel & Tee’s never disappoints. It’s one of those places where you can pop in for a quick look but end up walking out with something you weren’t expecting.
- Best for: Vintage clothing, collectibles, and furniture
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for high-end brands or modern home decor
- My Top Picks: Vintage clothing, home accessories, and small furniture
- Location: 4915 Hillsdale Ave, Erie, PA 16509
- Phone: (814) 881-7724
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Closed on Sundays
Best Consignment Shops in Erie PA
The Sassy Peacock
The Sassy Peacock is one of the best consignment shops in Erie PA, if you’re looking for stylish, gently used clothing at affordable prices. This boutique is a must-visit for fashion lovers, as it has a fantastic collection of trendy and classic pieces. The store is always neat and organized, with clothing arranged by size and style, which makes it easy to find exactly what you’re after.
Whether you’re looking for a designer dress or a chic pair of shoes, you’re likely to find it here at a fraction of the retail price. The atmosphere at The Sassy Peacock is warm and welcoming, making it a fun place to shop. The selection of clothes is carefully curated, so you can expect to see quality items that have been gently loved.
The staff are friendly and always ready to help you find something perfect. If you’re a bargain shopper with an eye for fashion, this store is definitely worth a visit.
- Best for: Designer clothing, accessories, and shoes
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for larger home items or furniture
- My Top Picks: Dresses, handbags, and shoes
- Location: 845 Pittsburgh Ave, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 833-0517
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 10 AM – 5:30 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Closed on Sundays
Sharp Consignments, LLC
Sharp Consignments is one of the best consignment shops in Erie PA for anyone looking to score high-quality, gently used items at reasonable prices. Whether you’re on the hunt for clothing, home goods, or even furniture, this store has it all.
The selection is always diverse, and you’re likely to find some great deals on items that are still in fantastic condition. From sofas to stylish jackets, the variety makes it easy to find something that suits your needs.
The staff at Sharp Consignments are friendly and knowledgeable, making your shopping experience pleasant. They’re always happy to answer any questions and provide assistance as needed. It’s a great place to find affordable, stylish pieces that can make your home or wardrobe feel fresh and new without breaking the bank.
- Best for: Gently used furniture, home goods, and clothing
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for high-end or designer brands
- My Top Picks: Furniture, home accessories, and vintage clothing
- Location: 2105 Hershey Rd, Erie, PA 16509
- Phone: (814) 520-5133
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 11 AM – 7 PM
- Saturday: 9 AM – 5 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 5 PM
Bitty Bungalow Project
Bitty Bungalow Project is a secret spot in Erie for anyone who loves consignment shopping. Specializing in unique and upcycled items, the store offers a variety of home goods, furniture, and clothing, all at affordable prices. It’s the ideal place for those looking for something different to add to their home or wardrobe.
The store has a relaxed, cozy vibe, and everything is organized in a way that makes it easy to browse and find something special. What sets Bitty Bungalow Project apart is the mix of vintage finds and creative, repurposed items.
Whether you’re hunting for a statement piece of furniture or a cool, unique outfit, this shop has something for everyone. The friendly staff always makes shopping here an enjoyable experience, and you’re sure to leave with a new treasure each time.
- Best for: Home goods, furniture, and vintage clothing
- Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking brand-new or mass-produced items
- My Top Picks: Furniture, vintage home decor, and unique clothing
- Location: 1624 W 22nd St, Erie, PA 16502
Best Second Hand Stores in Erie PA for Furniture
City Mission Shop and Drop Off
City Mission Shop and Drop Off is a good option if you’re looking for cheap thrift stores in Erie PA that also give back to the community. Not only does this store offer a wide variety of affordable items, but your purchases also support a local cause, which makes the shopping experience feel even better.
From clothing to furniture, you’ll find plenty of gently used treasures that are both functional and stylish. The prices are fair, and the selection is diverse, so there’s always something for everyone. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly, which makes shopping here a pleasant experience.
It’s a great place to pop in and browse, knowing you’ll find good deals while also helping support those in need. Whether you’re looking to furnish your home on a budget or score some quality clothing, City Mission Shop and Drop Off is worth a visit.
- Best for: Bargain hunting, furniture, household items
- Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking brand-new or high-end products
- My Top Picks: Furniture, home decor, and clothing
- Location: 2064 W 15th St, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 487-8189
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Saturday: 10 AM – 6 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM – 5 PM
- Closed on Sundays
Best Vintage Thrift Stores in Erie PA
Vintage Wonderland and Curiosity Shop
Vintage Wonderland is a must-visit store for anyone who loves quirky and unique vintage treasures in Erie. This shop is a true gem, offering everything from retro furniture to unique items that you won’t find anywhere else. The prices are very reasonable considering the quality of the items, and it’s a great spot to shop for something special.
If you’re looking to decorate your home with a touch of nostalgia or find vintage clothing that stands out, this is the place to be. The store has a cozy and welcoming atmosphere that makes browsing fun and relaxed. The staff are knowledgeable and always happy to talk about the history behind the items in the shop.
Whether you’re a long-time vintage lover or just getting into it, you’ll find something that catches your eye. It’s a great place to pick up some unique pieces and support a local business at the same time.
- Best for: Vintage furniture, retro collectibles, and unique decor
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for modern or mass-market items
- My Top Picks: Retro decor, vintage furniture, and old-fashioned toys
- Location: 3705 W Lake Rd, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 806-8187
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday-Saturday: 12 PM – 7 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 6 PM
Oregon Antiques
Oregon Antiques is one of the best vintage thrift stores in Erie PA, for those who love unique and antique items. This shop specializes in a wide variety of antiques, from elegant furniture to quirky collectibles that you won’t find anywhere else.
The store is well-organized, making it easy to browse through their extensive collection. Whether you’re redecorating your home or just love the charm of vintage items, you’re sure to find something special that adds character to your space.
The staff at Oregon Antiques are friendly and knowledgeable, always happy to assist you in finding the perfect piece. With its clean, well-maintained items and reasonable prices, it’s a great place for anyone looking to add a unique, antique touch to their home decor. It’s a must-visit for vintage lovers in Erie.
- Best for: Antique furniture, home decor, and collectibles
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for newer, mass-produced items
- My Top Picks: Antique furniture, glassware, and vintage accessories
- Location: 3436 W Lake Rd, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 836-0737
- Operating Hours:
- Monday-Friday: 11 AM – 4 PM
- Saturday: 10 AM – 4:30 PM
- Sunday: 12 PM – 3 PM
The Dollhouse At Pointe Foure Boutique
The Dollhouse is one of the best consignment shops in Erie PA for anyone in search of curated, stylish, and high-quality items. This boutique-style thrift store offers a mix of elegant vintage clothing and charming home decor, perfect for those with an eye for beauty and uniqueness.
Every piece is thoughtfully selected, making it easy to find something special that stands out. Whether you’re after a fashionable outfit or a unique decorative item, The Dollhouse has plenty of options to suit your taste. The store’s cozy atmosphere and welcoming staff create an enjoyable shopping experience.
It’s the kind of place where you can spend time browsing and always find something new to fall in love with. If you enjoy hunting for rare and elegant treasures, The Dollhouse is definitely worth checking out.
- Best for: Curated vintage clothing, accessories, and home decor
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for everyday basics or furniture
- My Top Picks: Vintage dresses, statement accessories, and home decor
- Location: 423 State St, Erie, PA 16501
- Phone: (814) 453-4080
- Operating Hours:
- Wednesday – Friday & Monday: 11 AM – 5 PM
- Saturday & Sunday: 11 AM – 4 PM
- Closed on Tuesdays
Best Furniture Thrift Stores in Erie PA
Presque Isle Militaria, Antiques, and Collectibles
For history enthusiasts and collectors, Presque Isle Militaria is a must-visit spot in Erie. Specializing in military memorabilia, antiques, and unique collectibles, this store offers a fascinating selection that’s perfect for those interested in the past. Whether you’re on the hunt for vintage military gear or rare antique pieces, you’re sure to find something special.
The store may be small, but it’s packed with items that have great historical significance. If you’re a collector or simply enjoy learning about history through artifacts, this is the place to be. The items are well-curated, and you can feel the passion behind each piece.
The staff is knowledgeable and happy to share insights about the items they carry, making it a rewarding stop for anyone looking for something truly unique. It’s definitely a store for those who appreciate history and treasure hunting.
- Best for: Military memorabilia, antiques, and collectibles
- Not ideal for: Shoppers seeking general home goods or clothing
- My Top Picks: Military items, antique toys, and rare collectibles
- Location: 811 W 26th St, Erie, PA 16508
- Phone: (814) 449-1150
- Operating Hours:
- Thursday-Saturday: 1 PM – 5 PM
- Closed Sunday-Wednesday
Best Cheap Thrift Stores in Erie PA
Cauldron & Thorne
If you’re into metaphysical and mystical items, Cauldron & Thorne is a unique store that offers a unique shopping experience. Specializing in crystals, candles, tarot cards, and other spiritual goods, it’s a haven for anyone interested in the mystical arts.
The store’s selection is vast, featuring everything from magical decor to incense and books on spiritual practices, making it a great spot for both beginners and seasoned spiritual practitioners. The atmosphere is calm and inviting, creating the perfect environment for browsing and discovering new items.
The staff is incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to offer guidance on the best products for your needs. Whether you’re looking for something to enhance your spiritual journey or just curious about the mystical world, Cauldron & Thorne offers a little bit of magic for everyone.
- Best for: Metaphysical supplies, crystals, and candles
- Not ideal for: Shoppers looking for traditional thrift items like clothes or furniture
- My Top Picks: Crystals, incense, and tarot cards
- Location: 2724 W 8th St, Erie, PA 16505
- Phone: (814) 790-5488
- Operating Hours:
- Monday: Closed
- Tuesday-Saturday: 11 AM – 6 PM
- Sunday: 11 AM – 5 PM
Frequently Asked Questions
Final Words
Thrift shopping in Erie is an adventure, with plenty of great finds at every turn. Whether you’re looking to add something unique to your wardrobe, decorate your home on a budget, or simply enjoy the thrill of a good bargain, the city’s thrift stores offer something for everyone.
Plus, you’ll be supporting local businesses and helping reduce waste by giving items a second life. So next time you’re in Erie, make sure to visit these incredible spots, you never know what treasures you might discover! Happy thrifting!
